Table of Contents[Hide][Show]
Salt is often a hotly debated topic in the natural health community. It was literally once worth its weight in gold, and now added dietary salt has come under scrutiny in the health and medical communities.
The problem with the advice to avoid salt is that studies about salt intake almost all use basic chemical table salt (NaCl). Research definitely supports avoiding a concentrated chemical source of salt like table salt, but when it comes to natural forms of salt, the research is not so clear cut.
The Amount Matters
There seems to be a golden ratio for salt consumption based on the research, and it is actually higher than the current RDA and the current US average consumption. In fact, the Japanese (and several other cultures) consume much more salt than Americans and have lower rates of the problems often blamed on salt intake (high blood pressure, heart disease, etc).
As Chris Kresser details:
According to research, there exists a range of sodium intake that likely confers the best health outcomes for most people. As I explained in part 3, findings from a 2011 study demonstrate the lowest risk of death for sodium excretion between 4000 and 5990 milligrams per day. (1) Sodium excretion greater than 7000 milligrams or less than 3000 milligrams per day was associated with a higher risk of stroke, heart attack and death. This lowest risk range equates to approximately two to three teaspoons of salt per day.
It is important to note that this golden amount of 2-3 teaspoons includes added and naturally occurring salts in foods like seafood. For most people eating an unprocessed diet, this amount is usually achieved naturally by eating a real food diet high in green vegetables and salting food to taste.
It is also important to note that consuming too little salt carries its own share of problems:
While salt-induced hypertension is typically blamed as a cause of heart disease, a low salt intake is associated with higher mortality from cardiovascular events. A 2011 study in the Journal of the American Medical Association demonstrates a low-salt zone where stroke, heart attack and death are more likely. Compared with moderate sodium excretion, there was an association between low sodium excretion and cardiovascular (CVD) death and hospitalization for coronary heart failure. These findings demonstrate the lowest risk of death for sodium excretion between 4 and 5.99 grams per day.
Another 2011 study confirmed this observation; not only was lower sodium excretion associated with higher CVD mortality, but baseline sodium excretion did not predict the incidence of hypertension, and any associations between systolic pressure and sodium excretion did not translate into less morbidity or improved survival. (source)
The majority of modern day salt intake (in the US) comes from processed foods. It is impossible to separate this salt consumption (which is the processed chemical form anyway) from the other chemicals, vegetable oils, and sugars found in processed food.
The Type of Salt Matters!
The fact that obesity and heart disease rates have risen over the last five decades while salt intake has remained the same suggests that if salt intake does affect cardiovascular and overall health, it doesn’t affect it in the way we thought. Real natural salt is a source of many minerals as well as just sodium and chloride, and there is a biological need for these minerals in specific ratios.
So is there a biological need for salt, and can it be fulfilled with a no-salt added diet? From Kresser again:
Not surprisingly, the move from a hunting-and-gathering diet to one consisting largely of grains and vegetables necessitated the procurement of supplemental dietary salt. Humans, like many carnivores, can meet their salt needs by eating meat and seafood, provided they do not sweat excessively. For example, the Masai, nomadic cattle herders in East Africa, can easily obtain adequate dietary salt by drinking the blood of their livestock. In modern and historic hunter-gatherer societies, it has generally been found that hunting tribes do not make or trade salt, unlike agricultural tribes, and once humans began cultivating crops, their dietary need for salt increased.
So perhaps modern diet precipitates our need for additional dietary salt. That being said, not all salts are created equal and I think it is vitally important to do your own research on salt and to consume it in proper ratios with other minerals and vitamins.
Many modern low-salt or “healthy salt” products are using potassium chloride in place of sodium chloride, which seems to be much more dangerous long-term (but which is a topic for its own post).
Best Kind of Natural Salt?
It is important to note the difference between naturally occurring salts and isolated NaCl (table salt- sometimes with iodine added). In general, what we just call “salt” can be one of three types: Table salt, Sea Salt or Rock Salt.
Table Salt is the salt you find on restaurant tables and on processed food. It is an industrial product made in factories and heated to over 1000 degrees. Often, aluminum hydroxide (an anti-caking agent) and other chemicals are added, along with iodine (which has its own cautions and which should be consumed in natural sources in ratio with selenium).
This is the salt often used in studies about sodium consumption. Large amounts of these elements in isolation, especially with added iodine, which can potentially lead to thyroid problems, may be causing more harm than good. In fact some research is exploring the possibility that sodium chloride in isolated form could be one of the factors in the increase in autoimmune disease in recent decades. (source)
This type of salt is also devoid of the natural minerals found in naturally derived salt.
Especially with Hashimotos, I avoid table salt completely.
As the name suggests, sea salt is salt mined from the sea. It is higher in minerals than table salt, and considered a more natural form. There are many variations of Sea Salt and the quality varies greatly. I’ve used Celtic Sea Salt and Real Salt. Both have a wide range of trace minerals.
The only cautions with Sea Salt are to not consume dead sea salt (too much bromide) and to make sure all sea salt comes from an un-contaminated source.
Himalayan salt is a type of rock salt mined from ancient salt beds in the Himalayan mountains. Since these salt beds are ancient an dried, they don’t have the contamination risk of modern sea salts and contain dozens of other trace minerals. From here:
Himalayan Pink Salt has a rich mineral content that includes over 84 minerals and trace elements such as: calcium, magnesium, potassium, copper and iron. This salt is recognized for its beautiful pink color, high mineral content, and its therapeutic properties. Regular consumption of Himalayan Pink Salt provides essential minerals, trace elements, balances electrolytes, supports proper nutrient absorption, eliminates toxins, balances the body’s pH, normalizes blood pressure, and increases circulation and conductivity. It can also assist with relief from arthritis, skin rashes, psoriasis, herpes, and flu and fever symptoms.
This is the type of salt our family uses most often and I buy it in bulk. I consider this the gold standard of salt and consume it regularly.
The Bottom Line
Biological need for salt varies by individual depending on age, activity level and health conditions. Always do your own research and check with a medical professional, especially if you have any medical conditions.
Natural salt doesn’t deserve the bad reputation that table salt has earned it, but it does need to be consumed in ratio with other minerals like magnesium and selenium and as part of a varied, nutrient-rich, real-food diet.
External Uses for Salt
Ever notice how awesome your skin feels at the beach? The natural minerals in salt can be great for skin. Here are some ways I use salt externally:
- Soak in a relaxing bath with added magnesium (epsom salts) and Himalayan or Celtic Salt (2 tablespoons of each).
- For skin issues: Make a poultice of real salt and water (or honey) and apply to areas with eczema or psoriasis.
- Make a salt scrub with finely powdered sea salt and natural oil (like coconut or olive) to use as an exfoliant in the shower.
- If you suffer from asthma or allergies, try a sea salt inhaler to help alleviate symptoms
- Use a Himalayan Salt Bar “Soap” in the shower to sooth and heal skin (some say this is very anti-aging) and is very gentle for children with eczema
- Use a Salt Deodorant Bar if you are sensitive to even natural deodorants
- Swish daily with a salt water mixture in the mouth for 30-60 seconds. The trace minerals in the salt will help remineralize teeth and the pH of the salt will help improve the pH of the mouth.
- Make a sea salt spray for skin– I’ve found this helpful as a natural toner.
- Use a DIY sea salt spray for a natural hair spray and texturizer.
- There is some evidence that a Himalayan salt lamp can ionize and cleanse the air. Either way, they are pretty!
Additional Reading about Salt:
Kresser: Shaking Up the Salt Myth and The Dangers of Salt Restriction and Healthy Salt Recommendations
Book: Salt: A World History
Wellness Mama: Are You Scared of Salt?
How do you use salt? How much do you consume? Join the conversation below!
Discussion (57 Comments)
i understand this has nothing to do with this post. I understand your a busy lady as well but I was wanting to know if you have any suggestions for helping my 8 week old with his congestion. If there is something you use for your little ones and you have a recipe I would love to see it posted.
I may or may not have at least 5 types of food grade salt in my pantry, and at least 2 3 types of cosmetic salts (epsom etc.)
The foodgrade salts are: Danish Smoke, Hawaiian Black, Celtic sea salt, Himalayan, white sea salt and that’s what I can think of off the top of my head. I have my eye on a Persian blue salt and I even get exited about it as I am typing this. Not sure why though, it’s just salt…
Katie, I am so glad you tackled the ‘salt is bad’ myth. I stumbled across that info on a 180 degree health blog a couple years ago. I was drinking too much water and always freezing and tired. My breastfed baby was cold and constipated. When I cut back on water and increased my salt intake we both felt so much better. She started putting on weight, pooing (TMI!) 2-3 times a day, and was warmer and more active.
I take a small amount a pink salt with my coffee (I take it like a supplement). It also helps us tired moms with adrenal fatigue.
I love your blog, keep up the great work.
We were using Herbamare almost exclusively for a couple years, but I’ve recently switched to an iodized sea salt. I don’t like the additives in table salt, but iodine is one you really can’t live without. There are many coastal cultures and ancestral societies that got enough iodine from their diet, but my understanding is that very few people get enough now (unless they’re real fans of seaweed).
I’ve been buying Celtic sea salt for a while now, but have been wanting to give Himalayan salt more of a shot since I bought a bag at the Wise Traditions conference. We’re HUGE salt fanatics in this family, so trying something new (to me) is exciting!
I consume Himalayan salt on a daily basis but heard recently that it contains trace amounts of flouride. Do you think this is a deal breaker at all?
Naturally occurring flouride is good for you. No, it is not a deal breaker.
In reference to the trace amounts of fluoride in the pink Himalayan salt….will that have any effect on being allergic to fluoride. Is the fluoride in the salt the same fluoride that is in water and toothpaste? I’m highly allergic to these, so should I stay away from the pink Himalayan salt? Anxious to know please.
How does bromide affect the body? We use a lot of dead sea salt and I wasn’t aware about bromide, but am willing to switch if I can understand the why’s.
Katie - Wellness Mama
This was the study I found https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20193810 and the reason I said that in the post.
Does that mean that Bromide (as Potassium Bromide cannot be ‘mixed’ with Himalayan Pink Salt??
Hi Katie. Sorry to reply on this comment but I didn’t have the option to leave a comment elsewhere. I contacted the co. You recommend for the Himalayan salt and they could not tell me how deep it was mined. I have read that it should be mined 5,000 ft or deeper. Is this not true? Thank you, love your articles!
I read a great article a little while ago about other kinds of salt – black, grey, blue – there are so many types I had no idea about! I’m with you on pink though – definitely my fave – if anything, for the colour! 😉
I was wondering if I can use Morton Sea Salt (Mediterranean Sea Salt) to make Sol?
When you look at the Morton Salt, is it colored with dark grains? If not, then it is heated at high temps to destroy all nutrients besides the mineral salt. It most likely also was run through nutrient extraction to remove higher-value content that is sold for more profit.
So far as I am concerned, Morton brands are worthless. Rather buy natural, unrefined salts. They are “contaminated” with nutrients!
I mainly use epsom salt for bath blends because it is extremely cheap. I will use Himalayan pink salt for consumption. I have tried the black lava salt from Mountain rose herbs for making charcoal soap bars and both consumption.
I honestly am not sure on average how much salt i consume, but i tend to keep my sodium levels balanced due to the large amount of water i consume. It is not usually high.
When my hubby went on a low carb/Paleo type diet, we switched from regular table salt to Real Salt. I can buy it in bulk at my local health food store for the best price. And we like it. Since Hubby is eating very little fruit or starchy veggies, he takes about 2 tsp. salt per day. If he doesn’t think he’s used that much by salting his food, he will take it in the palm of his hand with a large glass of water. I like to add a 1/4 tsp. salt to my large water glass, along with liquid magnesium and trace minerals and sip it.
I am wondering about iodine for those who do not take a mineral supplement. We started taking a electrolyte liquid which contains many trace minerals including iodine.
Because of you, I just bought my first Himalaya salt tea light holder (using beeswax candles or soy). I love the glow. And if it does good things for the air, all the better!
Thanks for all you do to help us stay healthy, Katie! XOXO
My homeopath suggested I take IODINE 6X for my iodine intake. Homeopathic remedies only give you the ‘energy’ of the mineral and its safer to take this. Having thyroid problems, I’ve started to lose weight now. Walking the dog daily – good hours walk – means I am getting two major chores done willingly now.