How to Make Whey & Cream Cheese

how to make homemade whey and cream cheese from yogurt at home How to Make Whey & Cream Cheese

I’ve talked a lot about fermented foods and drinks lately, from my favorite water kefir, to homemade sauerkraut. Lately, I’ve been enjoying trying things like fermented condiments, salsas and more.

Most of these recipes use whey to speed the lacto-fermentation process and for a long time, I avoided these recipes because I simply didn’t have and didn’t know how to get whey.

A friend and lacto-fermenting veteran shared an easy way to make whey, and I couldn’t believe I hadn’t started doing this sooner! The best part is, you can make whey at home in any kitchen with ingredients available at any grocery store.

4.0 from 3 reviews
Whey and Cream Cheese Recipe
 
Prep time
Total time
 
How to make whey for fermenting vegetables and other foods and get probiotic cream cheese!
Author:
Recipe type: Fermented
Serves: 4+
Ingredients
  • One 32-ounce container of full fat organic PLAIN yogurt
  • Cheesecloth or thin dish towel
  • medium-size bowl
  • string or rubber bands
Instructions
  1. Pour the yogurt into cheesecloth or thin towel. You can pour the whole container, or just use half if you don't need much whey. Make sure the towel is thin, as it will absorb too much of the whey if it is a very absorbent towel.
  2. Pull the ends of the towel up and secure with string or a rubber band.
  3. Tie the towel with yogurt in it to a cabinet handle above the bowl.
  4. Leave it alone overnight to drip.
  5. In the morning, if the dripping has stopped, pour the liquid in the bowl (this is the whey... yay!) into a glass jar and store in the fridge for up to six months.
  6. The "yogurt" left in the towel is actually cream cheese now. Put in its own container and use as you would store bought cream cheese.
  7. Use the whey for homemade salsas, sauerkraut, fermented veggies or pickles and more. (all recipes to come soon.... just waiting on the garden to start producing!)

Have you made whey before? If so, what is your favorite recipe using it? Share below!

Reader Comments

  1. Rebekah says

    I make a homemade yogurt, a gallon at a time, and always strain a quart or two. I just line a sieve with a coffee filter, put it over a bowl, and pour the yogurt in; let it drain for as long as you want, the longer the thicker. My husband loves strained yogurt (it’s like Greek yogurt, really creamy) and I also love having the whey.

    • Lynn says

      This is called lebany. In the middle east it is a staple food.

      We add a bit of pink or sea salt to it. We cut scallions (the entire thing), grape tomatoes (1/2’d or 1/4’d) marinate them in olive oil and white balsamic vinegar. Mound the very thick creamy lebany in the middle of a serving plate. strain (reserve a spoon full) the veggies and heap in a ring around the lebany. dribble a small bit of reserved liquid over the mounded lebany. It is so pretty. Scoop veggies and lebany onto your favorite read or cracker.

  2. Todd says

    Thanks for posting this! I may have to give this shot. I will soon make awesome foods like this as I have the time to make fermented foods.

  3. Stef says

    Question – what happens if you make this with Greek yogurt? That was the only organic yogurt I could find when I went to get some for this recipe. I have fermented my lemonade for 2 days now, and am now wondering if using Greek yogurt would affect how this works/doesn’t work. What say you? Thanks!!

    • Jackie says

      You can use young fresh coconut water. In a jug combine coconut water and water kefir grains and leave covered on bench for 1 to 2 days. When cloudy and some bubbles it is ready, strain out and bottle then refrigerate for a minimum of one day. Keep 1/4 cup to transfer to next batch.

  4. Mel says

    My dad is Turkish and claims the Turks invented yoghurt! He makes his own every week and strains it in a cheesecloth to make ‘Greek’ yoghurt. But he pours away the whey! He dies make his own pickles but I think he uses vinegar. Must tell him to start using the way instead of wasting it.

  5. Kristin Friesen says

    Is it ok to leave this out on the counter overnight, or does it need to be refrigerated? Seems like dairy left out all night will have gone bad by morning…?

    • says

      I’ve never had any trouble with it. It just sours more since it is a living fermented food rather than rotting, but you can just leave it out long enough to drain and then put it in right away.

    • says

      It does, but even pasteurized yogurt contains the live bacteria needed to lactoferment. Raw milk yogurt (or when) would produce a faster ferment and a wider variety of probiotics.

  6. Kelly Killeen says

    I see the whey lasts for about 6 months. About how long does the cream cheese last? Or would it be about the same date that’s on the package of yogurt?

  7. Jazzy Ann Smith says

    wowwwwww ! I didn’t know u can make cream cheese out of this! I have homemade yogurt just waiting to do this !

  8. Jazzy Ann Smith says

    How many hours is that if I do it right now? and can I half it, if I have only have 2 pints of yogurt?

  9. Ryan Jore says

    Just tried this for the first time…what do you do with all the leftover cream cheese? I can only eat so much of it plain…

    • Tammy says

      You can also blend a bit with a few strawberries and a touch of maple syrup to make whipped strawberry cream cheese. So yummy!

    • Margaret says

      Add pesto to it or pour sweet chilli sauce over it for a dip Oh so yummy.
      Make cheesecake, use on breakfast – thin with a little milk if very thick. On crackers, bread as a spread.

  10. Nollaig Lynch says

    I am very excited…I am trying my first whey production tonight. As we speak my whole organic natural yoghurt is drip dripping over a bowl. I am trying with a 500g carton and hope to make the half cup of whey to make fermented salsa…this will be my first time to make this also!!! My Q. is the same as Kelly’s below…how long will the cream cheese last? How should the cream cheese be stored – in a sealed glass container? And lastly, how can it be turned into sour cream – as someone mentioned below?
    Thank you Wellness Mama for your time. I am a newbie and just loving your web
    site xx

  11. Kara Downing says

    Does anyone know if you can successfully make whey with yogurt made from organic goat’s milk? I’m finding that it slips right through the cheese cloth!

  12. Danielle Honan says

    ive made this a few times and for some reason my whey keeps molding… i am using a really good organic plain yogurt and after a week it molds. Any suggestions?

  13. Lesue Tindell says

    I see the whey lasts for about 6 months. About how long does the cream cheese last? Or would it be about the same date that’s on the package of yogurt? I see this question below but no answer. I’ve made the whey a few times now and love the lemonade made with it! Just wondering how long the cream cheese will be good for?

  14. Kay says

    This didn’t work for me at all! :( I tried cheesecloth and then I tried butter muslin for a finer cloth and both times all the yogurt just went right through the cloth. I am using raw milk yogurt from a co-op is that a problem? Thanks.

    • Michele says

      I use clean flour sack cloth; I’ve found it them easier to work with than cheese cloth. My guess is that the raw milk yogurt is a lot runnier than store bought yogurt is; I know mine was when I used to make it.

  15. Doski says

    I tried this technique yesterday as I needed some fresh whey culture to ferment some mango chutney. I let it go about eight or nine hours using cheese cloth and then refrigerated what was left over night. I started with about 1.5 cups of fresh, jersey-cow, full-fat yogurt from a local farm; I only needed a 1/4 cup of whey but got about three times that so I have some saved for the next ferment.

    What was left is really like cream cheese. It’s not quite as thick as store-bought but I actually like it better. I mixed some with raw honey and then stirred in some left-over mango chunks and almonds for my breakfast and it is absolutely delicious.

    I’m sold on this technique. Now I’ll always have fresh soft probiotic cream cheese and never run out of starter culture for my vegetable and fruit ferments.

  16. Jhyana says

    We make our whey from raw milk. Simply leave a glass jar of raw milk on the counter, at room temperature, for a day or two until the solid separates from the liquid. Then proceed with the drip drying process. The solids are cream cheese, the liquid is the whey!

  17. Uni says

    Curious since all I have in my fridge is some old buttermilk. Is it possible to make whey and cream cheese with buttermilk?

  18. Amy says

    My significant other LOVES cream cheese, but I try to limit how much we buy because, well, have you read the label. Yikes! Finally, I can make some that I feel good about feeding him. And bonus, we get a nice whey to make fermented foods. Thanks Katie!

  19. Sherry says

    To make straining easier I use an old white pillowcase that is only washed with dish liquid, that or a cut up white tshirt. I started using these when I didn’t like the cheesecloth. I just dampen them a little first.

  20. Han says

    Hello,

    i’ve made whey months ago, and i haven’t finished using it.I stored it in a glass jar in the fridge. Today, i looked at the lid, and there is a lot of blue,white mold growing. I wonder why, it scared me so much. it is only on the lid.Should I continue on using the whey? I smelled it and it doesn/t seem to have a big yogourt smell, as i used to get when the last time i opened it though.Should I continue to use it? I dont understand why though. Should i discard the lid or wash it?
    i dont know what to do. Please HELP!

    • Michele says

      I personally wouldn’t want my food running through plastic. I use old flour sack towels as I don’t like working with cheese cloth that much.

  21. Cornel says

    Hi, have you tried making kefir yogurt with the milk kefir plant? This is the only yogurt I eat now as you make it with organic milk, so there are no preservatives, additives, colorants, etc in it and contains all the probiotics you talk about. I also drain it with a cloth to get the whey on the one side and cottage cheese on the other side :)

  22. Anderson says

    I am allergic to whey so I have been doing this to make cream cheese for years. I use an unbleached coffee filter in a colander and set it over a bowl to catch the liquid. I use plain organic yogurt without the tapioca, just milk and cultures. I leave it uncovered I the fridge for a few days so it dries out really well. Otherwise it will still “leak” whey out after a few days but you can just pour it off the top. To make really good cream cheese I add salt just like you would for making cheese. You can add dried herbs to some of it for a cheesy taste or sometimes I make a powder out of dried strawberries and mix it in for a fruity taste, I find the longer you let it drain the nicer the cream cheese will be. Sorry I don’t know about the whey since I can’t eat it. That is how I found out about making the cream cheese was because I was in search of foods I could eat without it. Almost everything packaged has whey in it as a protein source so I had to make things myself. Good luck on your fermenting. Blessings………………..D

  23. Eli says

    And by the way, do you think that I can make the whey from store-bought milk kefir? I think that it might have more beneficial bacteria than yogurt.

    • Billie says

      Yes, I think you can. Tho I’ve never bought commercial milk kefir, I’m thinking you will get a lot of whey vs cream cheese.
      I make my own milk kefir, and I use 1/2&1/2, and get a thin yogurt consistency. Every so often I drain it to make “cream cheese”, and also get whey.

  24. Kim says

    My whey has some drops of yogurt in it. Should I filter it again before I store it? I thought whey should look more like water than milk .

  25. Cassie says

    We have a bit of a pest problem that we are trying to resolve so i can’t leave anything sitting out all night. Can i still do this in the fridge or do i need to rig up an airtight container so the bugs don’t get in?

  26. christi says

    Mine has a few yogurt drops too, its not completely clear, this is my first attempt…. But it should be ok..? i hope so, been putting this off WAY too long… lol

    • Lori says

      You have to repeat. Although I’ve been making my own yogurt and milk kefir and since I like mine on the thick side i have lots of whey almost a gallon, since right now I’m having dentures made and am not sure on how well I will be able to eat the harder vegetables and if you heat them first, you kill the beneficial bacterias in the vegetables that allow them to ferment.

    • crazywoman/Billie says

      Yes, I think you can. Tho I’ve never bought commercial milk kefir, I’m thinking you will get a lot of whey vs cream cheese.
      I make my own milk kefir, and I use 1/2&1/2, and get a thin yogurt consistency. Every so often I drain it to make “cream cheese”, and also get whey.

  27. Veronica says

    The cheese you get from this is really tart and doesn’t taste like cream cheese at all. I think it taste more like goat cheese. So I couldn’t figure out how to use it and decided to top a burger with it and it tasted pretty good.

  28. Kelly says

    Hi there!

    Im making my first batch of whey using raw milk. Have you ever tried this before? I let it clabber for 24 hours and now have it straining. The whey doesn’t look clear at all. So Im thinking I need to let it sit longer? Could I bottle the “whey” I got and let it clabber longer and then try again? Thanks so much!

    • Carleigh says

      I was wondering the same thing! We have found raw milk (FINALLY! :)) and I’m wanting to make whey from the milk.

      • Brad says

        I was wondering the same thing ….. I’ve got raw goat’s milk that I can 1) drink plain & 2) make into yogurt… drain part of it to make whey & cream cheese or 3) just make the whey & cream cheese from the raw milk itself. I suppose I like the idea of making it out of the yogurt, since it’s already been cultured, added probiotics, etc. but it sure would be nice to make the whey straight from the milk.

  29. Tim says

    That’s because it is not cream cheese. Cream cheese has cream in it! This is strained yoghurt, despite what many comments say.

  30. Tim says

    Not sure why many people say the left over part is cream cheese. It doesn’t even taste like cream cheese and cream cheese has cream in it.

  31. Sara says

    Can whey been made like this from raw goat’s yogurt? Would there be any issue either with the ‘raw’ part or with the fact that it’s goat’s instead of cow’s?

    I have seen a few others comments above asking this question about using goat’s milk/yogurt, but haven’t seen any replies either way.

    Thanks!

  32. April says

    Can you use goat milk yogurt to make whey? And do you know if it would work the same in recipes??Thanks for your time!

  33. Dani says

    I love this and made so much yummy fermented salsa with it. Unfortunately we ran out of good ideas for the cream cheese? I’m loathed to try it again until I know I can put the cream cheese to use. Any ideas?

  34. Alaena says

    Trying my hand at fermentation recently. Loving it. Was reading up on lacto fermenting and it occurred to me that it’s essentially sippy cup cheese, or at least the water part of it. Allllll these years I knew there was something you could do with that stuff. (not that I’d use that for actual fermenting but….) DOH!!

  35. Kellie says

    My whey is yellow. I let it drip for over 24 hours. In the bowl it looked like it had separated somewhat. i just wisked it together and poured it through a strainer. Will it separate again? Did I do something wrong? It was definitely not clear. I used Stoneyfield Farm whole milk organic yogurt. The cream cheese tastes good though. I think I got that part right;-)

Join the Conversation...

Your email address will not be published. Please read the comment policy.

Rate this recipe: