, , ,

How to Make Bone Broth (Recipe, with Instant Pot Option)

Katie Wells Avatar

Reading Time: 8 minutes

This post contains affiliate links.

Read my affiliate policy.

Bone Broth Recipe with Tutorial
Wellness Mama » Blog » Recipes » Beef Recipes » How to Make Bone Broth (Recipe, with Instant Pot Option)

If you aren’t already making bone broth regularly, I’d encourage you to start today! It is an incredibly healthy and very inexpensive addition to any diet, and the homemade versions beat store-bought broth in both taste and nutrition (although there is some amazing homemade organic broth you can buy pre-made now).

This is the one nutrient rich food that anyone can afford to add!

What is Broth?

Broth (or technically, stock) is a mineral-rich infusion made by boiling bones of healthy animals with vegetables, herbs. and spices. You’ll find a large stock pot of broth/stock simmering in the kitchen of almost every 5-star restaurant. It is used for its great culinary uses and unparalleled flavor, but it is also a powerful health tonic that you can easily add to your family’s diet.

Broth is a traditional food that your grandmother likely made often (and if not, your great-grandmother definitely did). Many societies around the world still consume broth regularly as it is a cheap and highly nutrient dense food.

Besides it’s amazing taste and culinary uses, broth is an excellent source of minerals and is known to boost the immune system (chicken soup when you are sick anyone?) and improve digestion. Its high calcium, magnesium, and phosphorus content make it great for bone and tooth health. Bone broth also supports joints, hair, skin, and nails due to its high collagen content. In fact, some even suggest that it helps eliminate cellulite as it supports smooth connective tissue.

It can be made from the bones of beef, bison, lamb, poultry, or fish. Vegetables and spices are often added both for flavor and added nutrients.
Delicious Homemade Bone Broth Tutorial- How to make perfect bone broth

Why Drink Bone Broth?

Anyone who has read Gut and Psychology Syndrome knows the many benefits of bone broth and how it can improve digestion, allergies, immune health, brain health, and much more.

What isn’t as well known is that broth can help reduce cellulite by improving connective tissue, increase hair growth/strength, improve digestive issues, and remineralize teeth.

Broth is also helpful to have on hand when anyone in the family gets sick as it can be a soothing and immune boosting drink during illness, even if the person doesn’t feel like eating.

Broth is very high in the amino acids proline and glycine which are vital for healthy connective tissue (ligaments, joints, around organs, etc). The Paleo Mom has a great explanation of the importance of these two amino acids:

In addition, glycine is required for synthesis of DNA, RNA and many proteins in the body. As such, it plays extensive roles in digestive health, proper functioning of the nervous system and in wound healing. Glycine aids digestion by helping to regulate the synthesis and of bile salts and secretion of gastric acid. It is involved in detoxification and is required for production of glutathione, an important antioxidant. Glycine helps regulate blood sugar levels by controlling gluconeogenesis (the manufacture of glucose from proteins in the liver). Glycine also enhances muscle repair/growth by increasing levels of creatine and regulating Human Growth Hormone secretion from the pituitary gland. This wonderful amino acid is also critical for healthy functioning of the central nervous system. In the brain, it inhibits excitatory neurotransmitters, thus producing a calming effect. Glycine is also converted into the neurotransmitter serine, which promotes mental alertness, improves memory, boosts mood, and reduces stress.

Proline has an additional role in reversing atherosclerotic deposits. It enables the blood vessel walls to release cholesterol buildups into your blood stream, decreasing the size of potential blockages in your heart and the surrounding blood vessels. Proline also helps your body break down proteins for use in creating new, healthy muscle cells.

What Kind of Broth?

Homemade, nutrient-dense bone broth is incredibly easy and inexpensive to make. There is no comparison to the store-bought versions which often contain MSG or other chemicals and which lack gelatin and some of the other health-boosting properties of homemade broth. However, if you’re short on time, I recommend Kettle & Fire’s grass-fed bone broth because it’s pretty gelatinous and made with organic ingredients.

In selecting the bones for broth, look for high quality bones from grass fed cattle or bison, pastured poultry, or wild caught fish. Since you’ll be extracting the minerals and drinking them in concentrated form, you want to make sure that the animal was as healthy as possible.

There are several places to find good bones for stock:

  • Save leftovers from when you roast a chicken, duck, turkey, or goose (pastured)
  • From a local butcher, especially one who butchers the whole animal
  • From local farmers who raise grass fed animals (ask around at your local farmers market)
  • Online from companies like US Wellness Meats (also where I get grass fed tallow in bulk- they sell pre-made high quality broth), Butcher Box, or Healthy Traditions (I order high quality beef, bison, lamb, and chicken bones from them at good prices)

This recipe for broth is my favorite and is an adaption of the recipe in Nourishing Traditions.

 

Delicious Homemade Bone Broth Tutorial- How to make perfect bone broth

Bone Broth Recipe (Stove Top or Instant Pot)

Make nourishing bone broth at home simmered on the stove top or in the Instant Pot in a fraction of the time.
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 8 hours
Total Time 8 hours 10 minutes
Calories 16kcal
Author Katie Wells

Servings

16 cups

Ingredients

  • 2 lbs bones from a healthy source
  • 2 chicken feet (optional)
  • 1 gal water
  • 2 TBSP apple cider vinegar
  • 1 onion
  • 2 carrots
  • 2 stalks of celery
  • 1 TBSP salt (optional)
  • 1 tsp peppercorns (optional)
  • herbs and spices (to taste, optional)
  • 2 cloves garlic (optional)
  • 1 bunch parsley (optional)

Instructions

  • If you are using raw bones, especially beef bones, it improves flavor to roast them in the oven first. I place them in a roasting pan and roast for 30 minutes at 350°F.
  • Place the bones in a large stock pot or the Instant Pot.
  • Pour cool filtered water and the vinegar over the bones. Let sit for 20-30 minutes in the cool water. The acid helps make the nutrients in the bones more available.
  • Rough chop and add the onion, carrots, and celery to the pot.
  • Add any salt, pepper, spices, or herbs, if using.

Stove Top

  • Bring the broth to a boil. Once it has reached a vigorous boil, reduce to a simmer and simmer until done.
  • During the first few hours of simmering, you’ll need to remove the impurities that float to the surface. A frothy/foamy layer will form and it can be easily scooped off with a big spoon. Throw this part away. I typically check it every 20 minutes for the first 2 hours to remove this. Grass-fed and healthy animals will produce much less of this than conventional animals.
  • Simmer for 8 hours for fish broth, 24 hours for chicken, or 48 hours for beef.
  • During the last 30 minutes, add the garlic and parsley, if using.
  • Remove from heat and let cool slightly. Strain using a fine metal strainer to remove all the bits of bone and vegetable. When cool enough, store in a gallon size glass jar in the fridge for up to 5 days, or freeze for later use.

Instant Pot

  • Add the garlic and parsley to the pot if using, place the lid on the pot, and set valve to seal.
  • Cook at high pressure for 2 hours, followed by either a quick release or natural pressure release. Either is fine.
  • Let cool slightly, strain, and store in a gallon size glass jar in the fridge for up to 5 days, or freeze for later use.

Nutrition

Nutrition Facts
Bone Broth Recipe (Stove Top or Instant Pot)
Amount Per Serving (1 cup)
Calories 16
% Daily Value*
Cholesterol 2mg1%
Sodium 458mg20%
Potassium 57mg2%
Carbohydrates 1g0%
Vitamin A 1575IU32%
Vitamin C 5.8mg7%
Calcium 21mg2%
Iron 0.3mg2%
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.

Notes

Detailed stove-top timing instructions below.

Like this recipe? Check out my new cookbook, or get all my recipes (over 500!) in a personalized weekly meal planner here!

Bone Broth Instructions

The first step in preparing to make broth is to gather high quality bones. As I said, you can find them from sources listed above or save them when you cook. Since we roast chicken at least once a week, I save the carcass for making broth/stock.

Chicken for Bone Broth

I usually aim for 2 pounds of bones per gallon of water I’m using to make broth. This usually works out to 2-3 full chicken carcasses. If possible I’ll also add 2 chicken feet per gallon of water (completely optional!).

You’ll also need some organic vegetables for flavor. These are actually optional but add extra flavor and nutrition. Typically, I add (per gallon of water and 2 pounds of bones):

  • 1 onion
  • 2 large carrots (if from an organic source, you can rough chop and don’t need to peel)
  • 2 celery stalks, rough chopped
  • 1 bunch of parsley

bone broth vegetables

Since I make in bulk, I usually use about 4 times the amount of each of these. You can make in any amount, just multiply or divide the recipe up or down.

If you are using raw bones, especially beef bones, it improves flavor to roast them in the oven first. I place them in a roasting pan and roast for 30 minutes at 350°F.

Then, place the bones in a large stock pot (I use a 5 gallon pot). Pour cool filtered water over the bones and add the vinegar. Let sit for 20-30 minutes in the cool water. The acid helps make the nutrients in the bones more available.

Rough chop and add the vegetables (except the parsley and garlic, if using) to the pot. Add any salt, pepper, spices, or herbs, if using.

Making Homemade Bone Broth

Now, bring the broth to a boil. Once it has reached a vigorous boil, reduce to a simmer and simmer until done. These are the times I simmer for:

  • Beef broth/stock: 48 hours
  • Chicken or poultry broth/stock: 24 hours
  • Fish broth: 8 hours

During the first few hours of simmering, you’ll need to remove the impurities that float to the surface. A frothy/foamy layer will form and it can be easily scooped off with a big spoon. Throw this part away. I typically check it every 20 minutes for the first 2 hours to remove this. Grass-fed and healthy animals will produce much less of this than conventional animals.

During the last 30 minutes, add the garlic and parsley, if using.

Remove from heat and let cool slightly. Strain using a fine metal strainer to remove all the bits of bone and vegetable. When cool enough, store in a gallon size glass jar in the fridge for up to 5 days, or freeze for later use.

How to Use Bone Broth

Homemade Broth/Stock can be used as the liquid in making soups, stews, gravies, sauces, and reductions. It can also be used to saute or roast vegetables.

We try to drink at least 1 cup per person per day as a health boost, especially in the winter. My favorite way is to heat 8-16 ounces with a little salt and sometimes whisk in an egg until cooked (makes a soup like egg drop soup).

In times of illness (which doesn’t happen often) we will usually just drink bone broth until we start feeling better as it supports the body but is very easy to digest so the body’s energy can go to healing. In cases of stomach bugs or vomiting, bone broth often calms the stomach very quickly and helps shorten the duration of the illness.

If you don’t want to DIY, this is a great pre-made bone broth option shipped straight to your door!

If you aren’t already, make bone broth a regular part of your kitchen routine. It’s health boosting, inexpensive, and easy… you can’t afford not to!

This article was medically reviewed by Dr. Lauren Jefferis, board certified in Internal Medicine and Pediatrics. As always, this is not personal medical advice and we recommend that you talk with your doctor or work with a doctor at SteadyMD.

Do you already make bone broth? Will you try it now? Share your tips or questions below!

Bone broth is an incredibly nutritious and health-boosting food that is very easy to make. This step by step tutorial shows you how.

Sources

Become a VIP member!

Get access to my VIP newsletter with health tips, special deals, my free ebook on Seven Small Easy Habits and so much more!

Easy Habits ebook on ipad
Katie Wells Avatar

About Katie Wells

Katie Wells, CTNC, MCHC, Founder of Wellness Mama and Co-founder of Wellnesse, has a background in research, journalism, and nutrition. As a mom of six, she turned to research and took health into her own hands to find answers to her health problems. WellnessMama.com is the culmination of her thousands of hours of research and all posts are medically reviewed and verified by the Wellness Mama research team. Katie is also the author of the bestselling books The Wellness Mama Cookbook and The Wellness Mama 5-Step Lifestyle Detox.

Comments

1,512 responses to “How to Make Bone Broth (Recipe, with Instant Pot Option)”

  1. Kim Avatar

    5 stars
    My first batch didn’t gel, but I didn’t use chicken bones, I used beef bones. I cooked that 48 hours.

    This time I made it with neck bones and chicken feet – the only place I could find these were at the Asian food market.

    I roasted everything first for an hour on 350 degrees, saved the juices and then on my stovetop I put everything in a large stock pot, covered with just enough water to cover the bones, Brought to a boil then reduced the heat to the lowest setting. I added my spices the last 2 hours of cooking – peeled onion and carrots, celery stalks, bay leaf, parsley, thyme, turmeric, peppercorn, garlic cloves, and other spices. I strained everything, let it cool enough to pour into a large Tupperware then put that in a cold water bath then refrigerated. This morning I have a nice tub of gelatin.

    The “fat” later at the top is not hard, it’s rather jelly like but I was reading elsewhere that there are beneficial nutrients in that as well and it’s ok to keep this in your bone broth and so I did. Had it solidified I’d probably have removed it, rinsed it clean, t and stored it separately for future use in gravy making or roasted potatoes.

    I heated a glass today and drank the yummy goodness, gave some to my dogs mixing it in their kibble and they DEVOURED it, my chihuahua eats the gelatin straight out of the fridge. The glucosamine will be great for my aging doggies joints. Win-win.

    I’m keeping enough in my fridge to last a few days and the rest I stored in freezer safe baggies in my deep freezer for future use.

    Success! Thank you for sharing your knowledge, So happy I found this – I have some GI issues I’m dealing with and leaky gut so this will be beneficial.

  2. Johanna Avatar

    5 stars
    Okay, so I have the chicken bones, skins (?), and a few veggies in the crockpot. Unfortunately no feet! 🙁 My parents don’t like the crockpot or stove being left on overnight so I’ve had to put it in the fridge overnight and start again in the morning. It has probably been going for maybe 25 hours now over three days (with putting it in the fridge at night). It did gel a little bit but I added more water because all the liquid was evaporating, so now it is back to pretty thin. The bones have not gotten soft like I read they are supposed to. Am I doing this okay? What effect does the turning off/restarting have on the broth? Is there any hope of getting it to gel? I did not roast the chicken beforehand.
    Any help or advice would be appreciated!! Thank you!!!! This is my first try at bone broth and I am looking forward to it!!

    1. Shawn O'Reilly Avatar
      Shawn O’Reilly

      5 stars
      Johanna,
      First question is – did you use the apple cider vinegar? This makes a tremendous difference in how soft the bones will get, does not add or subtract from the taste, but it does make a difference in the bones themselves.
      Second question is did you use any chicken feet? That is what adds the gelatin to the broth – sometimes it will gel without the feet, and really, the gel does not add or subtract from the taste either, so it is not necessarily wrong for it not to gel.
      Finally, bone broth is really about the taste overall – if you taste it, and it tastes good, don’t worry about the bones, you got it right! The nutrients from the bones are in the stock/broth, and while I like to use the bones for the pets, even ground up in stock they don’t taste all that great to me, so pet food is about all I use the actual bones for anyway!
      Finally – need to watch how you cool the crock pot down when putting it in the fridge at night. To ensure that bacteria does not grow (in accordance with the health department) the temperature needs to cool to below 45 degrees in less than 30 minutes… most home refrigerators CANNOT comply with this demand. Doing it one night is fine, doing it two night… I personally would not trust it! If you have a deep freezer you can cool it that way in an hour, but make sure you check on it in an hour! If it freezes solid it will be a mess as it will expand over the edges. Also, I would not do this with a crock pot – ceramic has a tendency to crack or even shatter like glass if the temperature is rapidly decreased – again making for a mess, or even worse, injury from it bursting!

  3. Patricia Tucker Avatar
    Patricia Tucker

    5 stars
    I finished my first batch of beef bone broth but although the fat got hard the broth hasn’t gelled. any idea what I did wrong?

    1. Shawn O'Reilly Avatar
      Shawn O’Reilly

      Patricia,
      Did you use any feet? (chicken feet are the most commonly used) The big thing is that its not done wrong if there is no gel – the gel does not add or subtract from the taste – the taste is what is most important, because if it does not taste good, then you won’t drink it anyway… so go off of how does it taste?

  4. Kim Avatar

    I am not sure if I did something wrong………. if you drink it in a cup – is it supposed to taste like you are drinking a cup of liquid grease ?

    1. Dana Avatar

      I would love to hear someone’s opinion about this as well. Just made my first batch and it taste like an oily chicken soup without the contents. (Maybe this is normal??)

      1. Linda Avatar

        5 stars
        Dana and Kim, The quality of the bird and the type of parts used makes a difference. It isn’t just what you are doing right or wrong. It is essential to get a bird that is healthy, well fed and large enough to be fully developed. I have been making bone stock for years and sometimes it turns out rich and gelatinous, while other times it comes out runny and oily. I always do it exactly the same way. I can only guess that the animal itself has something to do with it. I’ve noticed that a good quality bird will make a really fine stock, while a scrawny bird makes a thin, runny, oily stock. Where chickens are concerned, I always remove the fat, whether it is oily or solid because I don’t think chicken fat is the best quality. The remaining stock is still useable and full of nutrients, but I never think the soup resulting from a thin, liquid stock is as satisfying as a thick, gelled stock. One thing that always helps is when you can obtain “parts” to add to your stock. Necks and feet make a stock much better if you can find them. I recently purchased a large quantity of duck carcasses and found that the stock was flavorful, but not gelatinous. What was missing was the feet and the necks. When making a beef or lamb stock, the type of bones used makes a difference because some bones have more of the marrow and connective cartilage tissue that creates gelatin. This is crucial. Again, if you can find hooves, it helps, but hooves are almost impossible to find as there are legal limits as to what parts can be sold and you would almost have to slaughter your own animal to get that. Anyway, it might not be anything you are doing wrong. I think it is easy to get too focused on the “method” because basic bone stock is super easy to do. There is more to it than your ability to do it right or wrong. There is an art to being able to recognize a quality animal and the accessibility to “parts” that are likely to produce the best stock.

        1. Shawn O'Reilly Avatar
          Shawn O’Reilly

          Agree with Linda 100% here! The only thing that I will add is what Grandma taught me with chickens… “The older the bird, the better the stock!” Fact is Grandma refused to use any chicken that was still laying eggs, and, “Roosters ‘r for fry’in, not for stock’in!” So she always used hens that were only past their prime for laying eggs.

          Tough to do unless you are using your own chickens, but a sure way to ensure you are getting a good chicken is to ensure your not using a scrawny bird – and ONLY use organic free range birds! I have found that vegetarian fed birds are not getting the proper scratch, dirt, minerals, and protein from bugs that they get in the soil – which can make for both scrawny birds as well as just weak tasting stock.

          I have been posting on other threads… the taste is what is really important, not necessarily that it gels. You can add chicken feet to other broths (beef, lamb, venison… etc) and it won’t change the taste and will add the gelatin, if that is what you are looking for. But to me, TASTE is what is most important! If you don’t like how it tastes, your apt to throw it out, so don’t worry about did it gel or not; does it taste the way that you want it too? If it does, then you have great stock!

          1. Annie Avatar

            Is there a difference between stock and broth? Chicken stock vs. chicken bone broth?

          2. Shawn O'Reilly Avatar
            Shawn O’Reilly

            5 stars
            In the true culinary world of chefs and such, broth is anything that is thrown into a pot with seasoning which is used for other dishes. stock, on the other hand, has nothing added to it – or essentially no seasoning… I may have that backwards as I am not a true trained chef… My training was from watching, and eventually helping my grandmother cook – she was synonymous with the terms, which is why I get confused even myself today!

  5. Denise Avatar

    5 stars
    Thank you so much for all the info. I just made my first batch of beef bone broth. Mine didn’t gel but I think I used too much water so next time I will try more bone and less water. I too, was worried about leaving it on the stove overnight so I just made room in my fridge and put the whole pot in and finished simmering it the next day. The fat was solid so it was easily removed and the soup was a nice color and clear not cloudy at all. I was worried it wasn’t going to taste like much but the next day it was quite delicious. I’m looking forward to making more and enjoying all the health benefits 🙂

  6. Linda Avatar

    5 stars
    What a great article on bone broth. I have made it regularly for several years and most of the time it is great. However, occasionally I wonder if something went wrong. This week’s broth is a good example.

    I cooked a stewing chicken in a crock pot (this is an old chicken that used to be an egg layer). The age of the chicken might have something to do with how it came out. The chicken was cooked for 24 hours on low heat. Although it was done, the meat was tough and rubbery, but I chopped it very fine and made it into a great chicken salad. Then, I returned the bones to the crock pot and added water and cooked the bones on very low for the next 48 hours.

    When everything was done, I strained the bones out and refrigerated the liquid until the fat separated. The fat never solidified and remained a cold oil on the top of the broth. The broth never turned to a thick, wonderful gelatin, and remained a thin, runny liquid. I skimmed off the fat and discarded and was left with a watery brown broth that looked more like a beef broth than a chicken broth. It isn’t a light, golden color like chicken stock usually is. It also has a kind of “overcooked”

    Normally, when I make a bone stock, the stock itself is a thick gelatin and the fat is solid. But when it turns out this way, I wonder if something has gone wrong and if it is still good to eat. It also doesn’t taste exactly like normal chicken stock – it has a heavily “roasted” flavor with a slight burnt aftertaste. Neither the chicken nor the stock was ever cooked on a high temp and nothing actually burned. I don’t know what to make of it when my stock is like this, but it makes me uncomfortable.

    I usually use a pressure cooker because I live in the Rocky Mountains, but this time my pressure cooker was otherwise engaged and I used my crock pot instead. But no matter what method I use, I get an occasional batch that comes out with a strange color, texture and taste. Not sure what I’m doing differently.

    What do you think? Do you ever have a stock that turns out like this? Would you still consume it?

    Thanks for any insight you can give!
    ~Linda~

    1. Shawn O'Reilly Avatar
      Shawn O’Reilly

      I had the same problem with some marrow bones that I had left over a while back as well… roasted them up, and they tasted great, but had more than I could use in the short amount of time that they would have remained good, so I froze the remainder… problem was that they got a little burnt in the freezer cause I forgot that they were there! So like many people – “Waste-not-want-not” theory went into practice and I tried to make them into a small batch of stock. What I got was an awful weak and ugly looking stock that smelled both burnt and rancid at the same time – my wife was mad as a hornet at me for a week solid from stinking up the house!

      Very rarely does this ever happen, but it does – I don’t know if it was something that the animal consumed that made it come out in the stock, if it is the freezer that ends up in the taste… guess there is a lot of factors that could play into how exactly the stock will turn out. But as in many of my other posts – the big thing is TASTE! Cause if it don’t taste good, then its just plain not good, and it gets thrown down the sink!

      In my 20+ years of making stock, and an additional 20+ years of drinking Grandma’s stock before that, I think I have botched up only a handful of stocks – so it is rare that it happens, but it does happen! Funny thing is, I don’t ever remember Grandma screwing up a batch of stock… so maybe there is still something I have not learned!

  7. Elaine Halleck Avatar
    Elaine Halleck

    After reading about bone broth here, I tried it for eczema in my ears. I’d had the eczema for a long time and it was very itchy and frustrating. I started with about 5 cups a day. After just a few days of this the eczema was virtually gone (and this was after suffering with it for years). Applying a little A&D ointment in the outer parts of my ears (not deep inside) was the coup de grace.

    I considered this practically a miraculous cure! I am really grateful to Wellness Mama and her blog.

    My only question is: I simmer the same bones daily (in water with a little vinegar) for months! Nothing bad has happened and I suppose the boiling makes it sterile, but I wonder if the broth still has the same nutrients after being used for so long. Does anybody have a clue?

    1. Shawn O'Reilly Avatar
      Shawn O’Reilly

      Depend’s on where you are at… you can ask the butcher at your market if they do their own processing – many don’t but they can order them for you. If you are in a bigger metropolitan area, look in the frozen section where they sell Asian items. Chicken feet are a delicacy in many Asian and South American countries, and I know in my local market they are found there. You can also try to look for specialty markets as well.

  8. Jim Avatar

    One correction on my last post, I commented that Cardamom was very powerful, I meant to say Cumin. A tiny amount can enhance the flavor, a lot will ruin the batch. If you are dissatisfied with a batch, heavens don’t throw it out. Freeze it in manageable amounts then use it as a base for beef stew, shepherds pie, onion soup…..

  9. Diann Avatar

    Thank you so much Jim. I didn’t think I had over cooked it (it was tasteless at 48 hours). I think it was your post I used to follow the 72 hour idea. I don’t think I used enough bones? Seems a terrible waste but it has no flavor. I think I’ll try a very small batch next time. My chicken bone broth is working nicely for me. ?

  10. Diann Avatar

    Hi. I’ve just started making bone broth and have been quite successful with chicken bone broth. I’ve been getting free range fed chicken necks and backs from a local farmers market. I decided to try beef and got some grass fed joint and marrow bones from the same source. I had about 4.3 pounds of bones and so according to the instructions I used 2 gallons of filtered water. I followed all instructions as noted (and have read most everyone’s comments). I roasted the bones and the carrots and onions. I added celery and lots of spices (peppercorns, rosemary, star anise, cardamom, thyme, bay leaves, oregano, etc). I also added parsley and a head of garlic towards the end. I simmered for 72 hours. My broth is absolutely tasteless and I don’t know what I did wrong. I’m so disappointed! Any thoughts?

    1. Jim Avatar

      Diann,
      Did you add the Apple Cider Vinegar? A must to break down the bone.
      The bone weight seems a bit light. Many comments here about gelling are related to too few bones. At the end of a batch I will pick out the best looking bones and freeze them for the next batch, so when I say 12-14# of bones below, that does not count about 6-8# of used bones. My batches never totally gell but the broth is thick. This is because I prefer to get a bit more quantity.
      Did the veg cook for 72 hrs? I add mine for the last 8-10 hours. They won’t hold up to the long cook.
      You have a good compliment of spices, ditto about adding for the last 8 hrs or so. I also grind the hard spices in the coffee grinder. Spices will not hold up to the long cook either.
      I found that I regularly need a flavor enhancer to get the broth to the consistency my wife will drink, try tomato paste, coconut aminos (I buy it by the gallon to cut costs) and tiny amounts of fish oil 🙂
      Cardamom is great but extremely powerful and it is easy to wreck a batch if adding too much.
      For reference here is my typical batch:
      18 quarts water to 12-14# of joint and marrow bones plus used bones. After roasting the bones I take out the marrow and put in the fridge. When the batch is completely finished I put the marrow in the blender with hot broth and mix it up then add it to the batch of broth, this aids in enhancing the flavor.
      The bones cook away with 1 1/2 cups of ACV for 3-4 days at about 210 degrees, I stir them 1-2 times per day.
      I will add the veg and spices before going to bed on the last night, not bothering to roast the veg as I have found no positive reason to do so. The spices are in rather large quantities, a cup of herbs de provence, 12-15 star anise, 1/2 cups of onion and garlic powders, multi tablespoons of other spices you mentioned. I buy them in bulk from Mountain Rose Herbs because I would go bankrupt buying them at the market. This batch also gets 5# of Onions, 5# of carrots, a head of celery. Once I strain it all out mid-day on the next day, I’ll start adding the tomato, aminos, fish oil, salt, sometimes organic Worcestershire sauce.

      When trying new spices take out about a half cup of broth then add the spice you are interested in then, then taste it. Beats ruining a batch with a flavor you dislike. Also helps you learn how powerful each spice is.

      I hope this is of some help, good luck.

    2. Kate Avatar

      5 stars
      Diann, I have used similar bone to water ratio and although it hasn’t gelled it tastes amazing! I never roasted the veggies 1st though. I tried the 72 hour simmer but it was too rich for my taste. Still good and flavorful but strong. Maybe roasting the veggies made a difference??

  11. Annie Avatar

    Does anyone have any insight on whether bone broth, and consuming collagen in general, is good for someone with Scleroderma (excess collagen, Autoimmune disease)? Thanks!

  12. Jim Gordon Avatar
    Jim Gordon

    5 stars
    At first I would use a meat thermometer and try to get the water stable between 200 to 210 degrees. Now I can look in the pot and see the slow, small bubbles that tell me the temp is good.

    1. Sue Avatar

      How do you cook it for 24 to 48 hours? Do you put it in the fridge when you sleep? Or do you just leave it on the stove until the next morning?

      1. Annie Avatar

        I put it in my crockpot for 48 hours and don’t have to worry about it. I use enough water to cover all the bones. I’ve never had to add water, but maybe because it has a good seal.

  13. Rick Avatar

    3 stars
    The scum is denatured protein,not impurities mostly comprising the same proteins that make up egg whites. It is harmless and flavorless, but visually unappealing. Eventually, the foam will break up into microscopic particles and disperse into your stock, leaving it grayish and cloudy. The more vigorously your stock bubbles, the faster this process will occur.

  14. Mike Strand Avatar
    Mike Strand

    Isn’t collagen and gelatin just broken down by your body to its constituent amino acids like any other protein? How would they then have any special properties to help with leaky gut or joint issues more than all other proteins sources?

  15. dana Avatar

    Hi wellness mama- wondering what kind of spices you put in your stock and how much ?

  16. Dana Avatar

    Hi wellness mama! A couple questions here.. For poultry broth can you use wild pheasant carcass? Also.. For beef broth what kinds of bones do you use from the cow? Any? And last one… I here you talk about the gelatin in the broth .. Is that the hard jelly stuff when it cools and what’s that good for? So u eat it cold and jelly like or heat and drink?

    1. Wellness Mama Avatar

      You can use any fowl, and for beef, the best are joint/knuckle bones and marrow bones but any will do (you will just get the most gelatin into your broth from joints). I heat my soup up to consume it.

4.64 from 188 votes (93 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating