Why The New MyPlate Recommendations Won’t be on My Plate

Katie Wells Avatar

Reading Time: 13 minutes

This post contains affiliate links.

Read my affiliate policy.

Not on MyPlate
Wellness Mama » Blog » Health » Why The New MyPlate Recommendations Won’t be on My Plate

With all the news about the old USDA Food Pyramid being replaced by the new MyPlate (which only cost the government $2 million to create!) I thought that an in-depth look at the old Pyramid is in order. I actually had a post planned about how the Food Pyramid desperately needed to be updated, but the USDA beat me to it.

The Food Pyramid Gave King Tut Heart Disease

You are probably familiar with the old USDA Food Pyramid which recommends 6-11 servings of lectin, gluten and phytic acid packed heart healthy whole grains, followed by fruits and vegetables (always in that order), followed by low-fat dairy and lean meats. Fats, Oils, and Sweets were always to be eaten sparingly.

Besides the fat that I seriously doubt that most people consult the food pyramid before making eating choices… in the 20 years that this one has been in existence, people have, on average been getting sicker and fatter… not healthier.

Was the Pyramid the Problem?

Of course, the USDA maintains that this is simply because the pyramid is complicated and hard for us non-government-official-committees to understand, which is why their new version is an insultingly basic model.

The USDA hasn’t even considered that perhaps the reason people are getting fatter and sicker could be in part due to the upside down pyramid they promote and the “low-fat-heart-healthy-whole-grain” message that is promoted by the mainstream medical and nutrition communities.

In fact, the general reaction to the failure of current medical and nutritional advice seems to be to suggest that we eat less fat and more fiber, as evidenced by the new recommendations.

A Different Problem Entirely?

outdated food labelsThe USDA recommendations for an average person on a 2,000 calorie a day diet is to consume over 300 grams of carbohydrates a day. Consider for one minute the possibility that excess carbohydrates, not excess fat (which the USDA only recommends 65 grams of a day) cause problems like obesity, diabetes and heart disease, and even if Americans are only following half of the advice set forth by the USDA, and its easy to see why these diseases are rampant.

(If you want a great explanation on why carbohydrates/insulin, and not fat, cause obesity, check out the great book Why We Get Fat: And What to Do About It.)

The Lipid Hypothesis is Dead

Despite mounting evidence that the Lipid Hypothesis is dead (the idea that saturated fat and cholesterol cause heart disease) and that high carbohydrate intake is the culprit behind the bevy of modern diseases, the USDA still recommends eating limited fat and simply increasing fruit, vegetable and whole grain consumption to get healthier.

Even in the face of new data and evidence, the case against fat continues. In fact, recent research found that the ancient Egyptians, who ate healthier than we do by our own standards, had a higher rate of heart disease.

Until now, researchers thought that our modern lifestyle with fatty and processed foods caused heart disease, though after this study was released, they admit that they might not understand heart disease as well as they once thought.

Mummies with Heart Disease

The study, which evaluated the calcification in the arteries of Egyptian mummies found high rates of atherosclerosis. Nearly half of all the mummies evaluated had calcified arteries, and some of them were under 40 when they died.

According to the study:

The Egyptians ate more fruit and vegetables and less meat than we do and their meat was leaner. They also led a more active lifestyle and were not thought to have smoked. Given that they developed atherosclerosis anyway, Thomas said, it becomes even more important to take measures to forestall development of the disease as long as possible, including stopping smoking, eating less red meat and losing weight.

The Definition of Insanity

Cognitive dissonance at its finest! To recap- they ate “healthier” by eating more lean meat and more fruits and vegetables (as the USDA recommends) and ate little fat (which the USDA also recommends) and they got sick more often that we do. So the logical conclusion is… drum roll please…. that we need to eat even less fat and even more whole grains, lean meats and fruits and veggies. Logical? I didn’t think so either!

Perhaps if we get rid of meats and saturated animal fats all together and just eat all fruits, vegetables, and healthy whole grains, then we could be healthy! But wait, that doesn’t work either!

Maybe one day, conventional wisdom and the USDA will shift from demonizing fats and reconsider the idea that excess carbohydrates (sugars) and not fats cause heart disease. In the meantime, check out  this article about the harmful effects of sugar and form your own educated opinion.

And have no fear… the USDA is again here to the rescue with a new and improved version of the exact same advice!

Enter MyPlate…

While the outdated “Pyramid” was apparently too confusing for normal people to understand, the new “MyPlate” was designed to be easy to understand, and it is… insultingly easy!

It’s true that a visual representation of a plate may be easier to interpret for many people, but unfortunately, it is only going to help interpret the same bad advice.

The new MyPlate guidelines, pioneered by Michelle Obama, still suggest at least half of dietary intake come from starches and sugars (grains and fruit), less than 1/4 come from protein, and another 1/4 come from vegetables, which could also be starchy.

Dairy, presumably low-fat, is thrown in as an afterthought, that should be consumed as a liquid, preferably preceded by a “skim, 1% or 2%.”

Fat? Hmmm… I guess the $2 million dollar committee-based-effort just forgot to include the recommendation for any fat…

Afraid of the Fat Once Again

Maybe they missed all the recent information about major studies concluding that saturated fat doesn’t cause heart disease, or the meta-analysis showing no link between fat and heart disease,  or all the information presented by Gary Taubes in his (500 page) brilliant case against the lipid hypothesis.

Heck, a $2 million dollar effort can hardly be expected to examine all the information and present an unbiased conclusion, especially when the USDA is so busy subsidizing foods like corn, wheat, and soybeans to the tune of $20 Billion a year!

Now, this wouldn’t be so bad if the USDA were just offering these “guidelines” for free-thinking adults who are capable of buying their own food and making their own nutrition decisions. The problem is, these guidelines also dictate what children are fed at schools. (Though, this might be a good thing in some parents eyes)

This Won’t Fix the Problem

Further restricting fat and calories is not only going to do nothing for the childhood obesity epidemic, it is harmful to developing brains of children. In fact, not getting enough fat, or getting the wrong kind of fat (like vegetable oils promoted by the USDA) has been shown to have a negative impact on IQ later in life.

Yet, this new government-generated graphic is supposed to lead us all on the path to optimal health, even though the food pyramid (which was basically the exact same recommendations) has done the opposite… not that any of us could follow it, because it was so confusing. (eyeroll)

You’ve probably caught on by now that I’m pretty peeved at this latest attempt to intervene in our nation’s health, especially because the advice being promoted is going to damage health, not improve it (though I wouldn’t want government interference even if they were promoting the exact same thing I was).

The Real Problem

I’m annoyed because fat is not the problem, grains and excess sugars and starches are, yet the mainstream medical/nutritional communities continue to promote these ideas as healthy.

If people want to make the choice to live on Pizza, hamburgers and soda, they should absolutely have that choice, in my opinion. It is the fact that many people are being misled into thinking that a “balanced” diet of grains, sugars, and vegetables with a little protein and very little fat is actually the standard they should look to for health.

I’m annoyed that the “experts” are still telling people that it is all about portion control and “calories in, calories out” while these same people, trying to follow that advice, are getting sicker! (Not to mention it is much more about hormones than calories!)

It makes me sick that healthy fats (saturated included!) are still being demonized, and disease causing omega-6 Vegetable oils are still recommended. (Still not sure on the fats issue? Watch this documentary for free now!)

All in the Marketing

bad health advice

What the USDA lacks in ability to read actual studies, they apparently make up for in marketing. I’ve seen versions of this new and “improved” advice everywhere… even in our local hospital’s publication. The article on the right is from the magazine from our local hospital. It is supposedly “Your guide to a balanced meal,” and helps us interpret the new MyPlate recommendations.

I’ve included the text of the article below with my (highly cynical) commentary after.

Chances are your dinner plate is shaped like a circle, not a triangle. So it makes sense to think of your family’s food choices as part of a circle too.

Ok, we can chalk up one true thing from this article. My dinner plate is indeed shaped like a circle. I wonder how many government dollars it took to figure that out. As for the whole food choices being a circle, it reminds me of something I’ve heard before about food choices… oh yeah… “cause it’s the circle, the circle of life” (from the Lion King).

Pyramids vs. Plates, Oh My!

That’s the practical idea behind the government’s new MyPlate icon, which replaces MyPyramid. With MyPlate, what you see in the icon directly relates to what you put on your plate.

Brilliant yet again! That old Food Pyramid (which gave King Tut Heart Disease) certainly was outdated and all of us dumb people lacking in government credentials couldn’t really figure out that you were just telling us to eat lots of carbs, some fruits and veggies and very little meat, fats, oils and sweets. Of course, since your health advice has been such a smashing success over the last few decades, I can see why you’d want to update it!

Veggies and Fruit

An Easier Way To Eat Healthy. MyPlate is a simple visual reminder to build yourself a healthy plate at mealtimes. For busy parents, it’s a quick and easy way to tell at a glance whether children are getting a balanced meal too. Just remember these basic rules of thumb:

-Make Half the plate fruits and vegetables – heavier on the vegetables. Include red, orange and dark green veggies and colorful fruits.

One thing we agree on! Vegetables (and some fruits) are good and you should eat them. Of course, you guys lump potatoes (a tuber and a starch), corn (a grain) and even french fries into this category, but at least we agree on green vegetables. Also, I’d suggest more like half the plate of green, leafy veggies and some fruits on top, but that’s a small point of difference (I say tomato, you say potato, but whatever).

Thank goodness all of us busy parents have you to help us figure out what is healthy for our kids. Without you, we might never figure out that feeding them McDonalds every day or letting them drink soda is not a good idea. What a relief!

Grains and Proteins

-Make the other half grains and protein. Emphasize 100 percent whole grains, like whole grain breads, brown rice and pasta. Select fish and beans for some of your proteins, and when you pick poultry or meat as your protein food, chose lean cuts in small portions.

Great idea (sarcasm). We should certainly eat more grains than protein, since protein is only vital to hundreds of reactions in the body and is needed for cell growth and repair. Grains on the other hand… we need lots of those (sarcasm again!) to be healthy and get our fiber. We definitely shouldn’t worry about the fact that they are not nearly as nutritious as proteins, vegetables or healthy fats. We should ignore the harmful gut-eroding glutens, lectins and phytates which are causing autoimmune disease at record rates. In fact, since a couple pieces of whole wheat toast skyrocket blood sugar just like candy, candy must be good for us too!

As for the 100% whole grain thing! Thank goodness for those wonderful bread plants and pasta stalks. I’m so glad they don’t have to grind the grains up into small particles, which would increase the surface area and make them affect the blood sugar even more!

We should definitely eat beans instead of meat too, because it has some protein (and lot of carbs). When we combine the carbs from the fruit over on the other half of the plate with the hearthealthywholegrains on this side and the carbs from beans, we might just be getting close to the 300+ grams of carbs we are supposed to be eating a day according to you guys, even if we are diabetic.

Anything but Fat!

As for fats… those evil artery-clogging saturated villains… certainly they should be avoided. Never mind that they are needed for minor things like hormone production, satiety, healthy reproductive function and more and that they don’t actually make you fat (or cause heart disease)… avoid at all costs. Eat candy instead.

Pour a glass of fat-free or low-fat milk. You’ll get as much calcium and other important nutrients as from whole milk but with less fat and calories.

Oh yes, do that! Of course, the vitamins in milk like the synthetic Vitamin D in minuscule amounts do need fat to be absorbed, but who cares if you are absorbing them, as long as you are getting them! You can’t have your cake and eat it too (unless of course, you use wheat flour and count it as your heart-healthy-whole-grains).

Evil Calories

And calories, those are the bad guys! It doesn’t matter at all if they come from grains and carbohydrates (which raise the blood sugar, get stored as fat and wreak havoc on the body)  or proteins (which are needed for important functions like cell repair) or fats (which are a much more dense and effective source of fuel). As long as we limit those calories, we are A-OK! In fact, someone once gave me a bottle of fat free, calorie free, salt free salad dressing. I might just drink the stuff!

And dairy, we need lots of that! Of course, all other animals don’t drink milk after infancy, but dairy is such a healthy source of (relatively nothing since they pasteurize and process it all out) everything, we should drink it too… maybe instead of the salad dressing!

Keep Portions Sensible! Think small dinner plate not super-sized platter.

Well shoot… I was soooo looking forward to that gigantic salad I was going to have for dinner. but of course, that would be way more than half the plate of vegetables, so that isn’t good, and the other half would be lots of meat (and not the lean kind) with good ol’ fatty olive oil drizzled on top and nary a grain or dairy in sight. Yep, better not eat that! It won’t be nearly enough nutrients and way too much protein and fat.

Not the Salads!

What should I eat instead? Maybe a couple slices of blood sugar boosting whole wheat toast with some hummus, an apple and a potato… yep that would fit, as long as I wash it down with the fat free dairy…. sounds so much more nutritious to me!

And I should probably keep some of those super-healthy (sarcasm) 100-Calorie packs with me at all times so that I can eat small portions throughout the day because not eating every 2 hours would be like fasting, which would cannibalize my muscle tissue (or not!).

STEP UP TO THE PLATE. MyPlate was developed by the U.S. Department of Agriculture.

Wait a Second…

Wait, what? The U.S. Department of AGRICULTURE is telling us what we should eat? You mean those guys who approved Monsanto’s request to grow genetically modified crops and test them on their own? The same guys who bailed out Domino’s Pizza (lots of saturated fats there) to give the dairy industry a boost? That same organization who’s leader was once a top proponent for Monsanto’s push for genetically modified crops?

Now why would the USDA have any interest in telling us what to eat? They only regulate foods like corn, wheat, soybeans, processed dairy, factory meats…. oh wait! Oh… its all starting o make sense now! (Note to self: consider hiring USDA for brilliant marketing campaign)

It’s designed to translate the government’s 2010 Dietary Health Guidelines for Americans into practical information that you can apply to your meals. Together, these tools help you get the right number of calories for reaching and maintaining a healthy weight. That’s crucial at a time when obesity rates have hit epidemic levels.

Biased a Little?

How wonderful that we have those sweet, unbiased people at the USDA (who regulate all those heart healthy whole grains and low fat dairy) telling us to eat more heart healthy whole grains and low fat dairy. Surely, they are just concerned about the health of consumers and don’t care  one bit about where their funding comes from.

Measures like these will certainly reduce obesity, just as they’ve been doing for the last couple of decades under the government’s guidance (obesity rates have been rising). If only all of us dumb Americans had been smart enough to figure out that that pyramid thing was trying to get us to eat more whole grains these last few decades, we’d all be thin and healthy by now and heart disease and diabetes would be things of the past! (statistics show we actually eat less fat than we did a few decades ago).

(I’m practically choking on sarcasm by now, in case you didn’t notice!)

Food Variety

Many people also don’t eat the variety of foods needed for optimal nutrition and health. Both adults and children often come up short on fiber, potassium, calcium and vitamin D.

MyPlate helps you to remember to choose a varied diet.For gauging portion sizes, the old guidelines talked about servings. The new ones refer to cups for fruit, vegetable and dairy and ounces for grains and proteins – units more familiar to home cooks

Yes, we need more varied whole grains! Of course, vegetables have more fiber and potassium… and foods like sardines and bone broth (lots of fat!) have more calcium… and we could get some Vitamin D from, you know, the sun… but we do certainly have to include those grains and dairy in our variety.

There are hundreds of fruits and vegetables, but we can’t let all that variety cover more than half our plates! where would the beans go? and the lean meats cooked in oxidized vegetable oils? Certainly, we must limit our vegetables to half our plate so we can make room for our whole grains and small portion of lean meat…

What to Do?

The article concludes by giving you resources to read more from the USDA (sorry, not linking to it!) and the hospital’s own website. You could even hire a dietitian to help you eat all that stuff in case you still can’t figure out that you are supposed to eat a lot of heart-healthy whole grains.

I wonder when the USDA and the medical community are going to figure out that these recommendations won’t really help anyone be healthy. Of course, where do people go when they get sick? The hospital!

What a coincidence!

What Is The Solution?

Step One: Stop looking to any branch of the government for nutritional advice (especially one that subsidizes agricultural crops!)

Step Two: Do your own research and take responsibility for your own health! (Don’t take my word for anything… research it yourself!)

Some other bloggers have written excellent takes on this as well (like here and here). Tom Naughton also has a great take on the issue as well, if you are in need of a good laugh!

A Better Way

For my part, I thought that a few changes could help the new MyPlate actually look like something that I would put on my plate. If I had to stick with the same model, it would likely look something like this:

wellness-plate-better-my-plate-recommendationsBut, then again, if I wasn’t limited to a measly $2 million dollar budget because I’d spent all my money subsidizing corn, wheat, and soybeans, I might even design a really flashy plate that would help all of us who were “confused” by the pyramid to really understand what to eat. Though, mine would look like this:

Bottom line… if you want to be healthier, fill YourPlate with foods like meats, eggs, vegetables, avocado, coconuts, some fruits, raw full-fat dairy etc and limit anything canned, bagged, processed or frozen (especially if it contains corn, wheat, or soybeans).

What do you think? Is the new MyPlate a step in the right direction or merely a more insulting way of offering bad dietary advice? What would your plate look like?

Katie Wells Avatar

About Katie Wells

Katie Wells, CTNC, MCHC, Founder of Wellness Mama and Co-founder of Wellnesse, has a background in research, journalism, and nutrition. As a mom of six, she turned to research and took health into her own hands to find answers to her health problems. WellnessMama.com is the culmination of her thousands of hours of research and all posts are medically reviewed and verified by the Wellness Mama research team. Katie is also the author of the bestselling books The Wellness Mama Cookbook and The Wellness Mama 5-Step Lifestyle Detox.


42 responses to “Why The New MyPlate Recommendations Won’t be on My Plate”

  1. DK Avatar

    What would you recommend for vegetarian? Any suggestion would be appreciated. Thank you 🙂

  2. Yas Avatar

    Your plate looks great and I would love to eat this way. Unfortunately I was diagnosed with uterine fibroids, I’m 26 no kids. Every book and article I’ve read has said that meat and dairy should be completely eliminated to keep the fibroids from growing. They also say to stay away from saturated fats. Ive cut down on meat & dairy significantly and removed all processed foods but cannot bring myself to be a vegeterian. It’s frustrating trying to eat what I know my body needs but being restricted by trying to heal my fibroids naturally. Maybe surgery is my only option & then I can eat the way you suggest. Then again even if I have surgery I still have to eat and live in a manner that will keep the fibroids from coming back.

  3. William Norman Avatar
    William Norman

    I know this article isn’t new, but I just stumbled upon it this morning. Two of the links that interested me are dead. What is the book by Gary Taubes? What was the video link?


  4. Rena Avatar

    When I was pregnant my doctor told me a good rule of thumb for a meal was: 1 fist-sized serving of protein, 1 fist-sized serving of starch and 2 fist-sized servings of produce (especially veggies), plus drink plenty of water. I think I have read this formula elsewhere as well. Honestly, I think this is a good suggestion for the mainstream, because it is easy to remember, takes 1/2 your nutrition from produce and is not extreme.

  5. Magdalen Dobson Avatar
    Magdalen Dobson

    I’m not a proponent of the no-grains, no-sugar diet for mainstream consumption, although I think that there’s sufficient evidence suggesting that it’s optimal for some people’s bodies. Personally, I am able to eat starches and sugars in moderation while feeling good about my body. I try to vary my grain consumption from just wheat–oats in the morning, whole wheat at lunch, and potatoes, couscous, or quinoa at dinner–and keep sweeteners mostly natural and only at breakfast and for afternoon snack. I eat tons of vegetables and get protein from dairy, eggs, nuts, and beans (I’m vegetarian), and it works really well for me.

  6. Morneau_for_4 Avatar

    This is a great post. To beat candida, I am actually on a high fat (good fats), moderate protein, low carb (non-starchy veggies only for carbs). Real butter and coconut oil are simply amazing.

  7. April Grow Avatar
    April Grow

    I’ve spent years reading and experimenting with nutritional recommendations. Everyone makes such a convincing argument. Never tried low fat bc the processed garbage they add to it is so wrong. Also, it just tastes gross. Never tried vegetarian bc it is not a sustainable lifestyle without the current importing/grocery store system. I don’t think God intended something that would not have been feasible until the last 100 years. Plus, most vegetarians I know don’t eat that many vegetables, they just don’t eat meat. They sustain themselves on processed foods and soy products. I did low carb for several years bc it made me feel so much better (I didn’t have any weight to lose other than the 5 vanity pounds every woman has). But it always bothered me to eliminate an entire food group. I am always wary of anything extreme. And I love bread products. I love pizza! Last year I took a class on naturally leavened breads and it made a lot of sense to me. Using the natural yeast in the air instead of grocery store yeast (which is a byproduct of beer making) causes a chemical reaction that completely changes the nutritional profile of the grain. I’m not an expert in it, so I’m not going to try to explain the science of it, but I do know that it doesn’t make my blood sugar spike, and it doesn’t give me that coma feeling. It is the way that bread has been made for as long as bread has been made, until the last 100 or so years. I took my class from Dr. Matt McClean and his wife Amy, who has a degree in nutrition (or something like that. I think she is an RD). To me it was the missing piece. I knew that regular grains made me feel sick, but it has been a staple in so many diets throughout the millennia that I couldn’t understand how it could be this new demon of the nutritional world. Now I can eat bread (whole grain, naturally leavened) and it makes me feel good. I just believe in moderation. Not all vegetarian, not all meat, not all grains, not all fruits. I eat grass fed local meats, local raw milk, organic local produce (most of which I grow myself), full fat everything, and naturally leavened breads. I make most things from scratch. I buy very few packaged products (I have a real weakness for corn chips, but it feels so much more virtuous when I get the organic ones from Trader Joe’s. Practically a health food! 🙂 )

    As for the school system and lunches, it’s appalling. My oldest three kids are kindergartners and I already know that I have signed up for a lifetime of packing lunches. My first rude awakening was when they were in pre-k and we were in charge of snack. I made banana bread with freshly ground organic spelt, organic bananas, far less sugar than most recipes call for, etc. Not to mention it was delicious. I was turned away at the door and told I had to go buy something packaged from the grocery store. It is a law here that you can’t bring anything homemade to schools to share with others. I went and got string cheese and raisins. You can’t even send cut up fresh fruit. It has to be individually packaged foods. Which meant that the other weeks when I wasn’t in charge my kids got such garbage as gogurts (beyond nasty), froot loops, oreos, etc., three times a week. On St. Patrick’s Day when they were supposed to bring their favorite green foods, my kids chose sugar snap peas, broccoli, pears and celery (my fourth is only a grade behind them so I had 4 in the same preschool). I gave them no promptings. They chose their own foods. The other kids brought green cookies and cupcakes full of artificial colorings and other awful things. I’m not saying that my kids never eat junk food. At gran’s house they eat sugary cereal to their heart’s content. On Halloween they eat candy. For their birthdays they get whatever cake they want. Our rule is 90/10. 90% of what they get is the best quality, nutrition and taste. The other 10% of the time they eat whatever, but it is usually part of a special occasion like a party or holiday. They also get a piece of candy from the karate and dance class teachers after each class, which I hate, but I let them eat it. But they also beg to have some of my veggie juices in the mornings. I’m not the food nazi bc I know that most of what they eat is great. They don’t watch TV during the week and never play video games. They run around outside and play and ride bikes and climb and play in the dirt as much of the day as they can. When they come in at the end of the day and I give them a kiss I tell them, “You taste like dirt!” and they are so proud! We all choose our battles. Some women keep immaculate houses, homeschool, have perfectly groomed children. The battle I’ve chosen is food. I put a lot of my time and effort into the food we eat. Ok that was longer than I intended.

  8. sarah Avatar

    I agree completely. The government has no businesses telling people what to eat, especially people like Michelle Obama who is in no way qualified to give nutritional advice.

    1. Morneau_for_4 Avatar

      Amen. I will make the choices for my family, thank you (and not just in nutrition).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *