Cauliflower Mashed Potatoes

Mashed Cauliflower Fauxtatoes Recipe Cauliflower Mashed Potatoes

I love mashed potatoes, but my gut doesn’t. For some people, the lectins in white potatoes can bother the gut. White potatoes are tasty and have some nutritional benefits, but are nothing compared to this nutrition substitute: cauliflower!

This cauliflower mashed potatoes (or fauxtatoes) recipe is a great side dish for Thanksgiving or other holidays, or for a healthy family dinner.

Before you click away, hear me out… when prepared and mashed correctly, cauliflower has a very similar texture to mashed potatoes and a sweet and buttery taste. Most kids won’t flinch at the difference, and you can rest happy knowing you are squeezing in extra protein and nutrients. Top with melted cheese, and even the most adamant of veggie haters will give it a try.

If you have really picky eaters in your house, whip really well, and provide toppings like bacon and cheese- they won’t know the difference!

Mashed Cauliflower Potatoes
 
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
 
A more nutritious version of mashed potatoes made with buttery cauliflower instead!
Author:
Recipe type: Side
Cuisine: Thanksgiving
Serves: 8
Ingredients
  • 1-2 head of fresh cauliflower or 1-2 bags of frozen
  • 4 TBSP butter
  • 2 T cream cheese or sour cream (optional)
  • 2 T or more Parmesan (optional)
  • Salt, pepper, garlic and other spices to taste
Instructions
  1. Bring a couple quarts of water to a boil in a large pan and add cauliflower.
  2. Cook until tender (I suppose you could also use a microwave, but I've never tried since we don't have one and don't use them!)
  3. When tender, put into large bowl and add other ingredients.
  4. Use immersion blender or hand mixer to blend until smooth and creamy. This is the most important step... chunks of cauliflower are a giveaway!
  5. Sprinkle with extra cheese if desired and serve warm.

Ever tried a mashed potato alternative?

Photo Credit: Suzanne Perazzini

Reader Comments

  1. Lynn says

    I made this last month for cottage pie and while my son wasn’t thrilled (he adores mashed potatoes!), he never imagined it was …. cauliflower!! My husband, super duper picky, said I could absolutely make it again. WHOOHOO! And I had been so dreading trying this. Love your blog, btw.

  2. Kaye says

    My family loves this – just be sure not to add too much liquid -I did the last time I made it – it was too soupy.

  3. MH says

    I am looking for a low carb AND low fat sub. for mashed potatoes.  But with 4 tbsp. butter, 2 tsp. cream cheese and 2 tsp. parmesan cheese….I know you can sub the cream cheese with low fat cream cheese.  Anyone have any lower cal. recipe.

  4. Laelle says

    I’ve finally found another person without a microwave!  People seriously think I’m crazy.  But as you know, you don’t really miss it once you get used to not having it around.  In my last house it was out on the counter and I would use every few weeks to melt butter or something, but haven’t had it plugged in in over a year.  Last week I actually missed a potluck I was supposed to go to as my grass fed ground beef hadn’t thawed in time to bake the meatloaf I had planned.  I realized I was officially never going to use my microwave again when the thought of finding it in my basement and plugging it in to thaw my meat crossed my mind – but I immediately dismissed it because I just couldn’t do that to food I would eat or serve someone else!  Time to post it on freecycle :-) .  

    • Lorraine says

      Exactly :) At first I was desperate without it when it broke. But the time without it made me realise I didn’t really miss it at all. And the oven is so much simpler and lovelier ;) I also managed to get away with making good eggs in the fryer which was first for me. So I know I can change my daily habits simply because I know the no matter what I eat I enjoy it and no matter how it’s made I can enjoy it. So long as it is nutritious and safe for my body. Or as a cheat taste really delicious and suddenly take aways can even steer me away. Lol but I know now I can make my own firm meals of substitute grains and still eat my korma just in a healthy assured way. Anyway I don’t think I want the microwave my friend and I was going to get one when kitchen was finished. But nah lol I rather invest that cash if I had it into buying a food processor. Making cauliflower rice and all kinds of veggies. I can make do with hand held too though ;)

  5. Erin says

    Tried this last night and we loved it! I used one head but added more of somethings: cream cheese – about 4 oz (half of a foil package), half a cup of shredded Parmesan and I also added half a tsp of powdered garlic. We loved it! Thanks for a great idea.

  6. Sam says

    I am wondering if one could roast the cauliflower rather than boiling? I love the flavor that comes from roasting it, but I’m not sure if the texture would be correct for this dish. Anyone tried this cooking method?

  7. Will says

    Excellent recipe here again Katie! Thank you for all you do! We had an awesome island style Thanksgiving feast with a great side of mashed cauli! Aloha!

  8. Irene Tiger says

    These (as well as cauliflower rice) have become a favorite in our house! It’s great because it tastes just like its starchy counterpart, goes well with anything, it’s great for my diabetic dad, and even the non-paleo members of my family like it!

  9. Teia says

    I don’t know if it would work or not with cauliflower, but with mashed potatoes, I use cottage cheese instead of sour cream. I don’t even like cottage cheese, but I LOVE it with potatoes, and it is a much healthier substitute for sour cream.

  10. catherine says

    I would like to make this and cauliflower rice more often but there is an issue with the price of the vegetable up here during the off season…which is most of the year! Has anyone had success with freezing raw, pre-grated cauliflower? I tried freezing blanched chunks once and they tasted really weird after a only a month or two. Not freezer burn or anything, just weird…and very watery so I’ve been afraid to try again.

Join the Conversation...

Your email address will not be published. Please read the comment policy.

Rate this recipe: