Homemade Natural Creme Blush Recipe

How to make natural creme brush and bronzer from skin improving ingredients

I’ve been experimenting with homemade makeup for years and have a powdered blush that I love and that works really well, but I’ve gotten several requests for a creme/liquid option. I was working on a liquid foundation recipe anyway so I decided to work on a creme blush as well.

Check out the original liquid foundation post for the specifics on how to customize this recipe to be thicker or thinner (or even oil free).

Crème Blush

The benefit of a Crème blush is that it stays longer and can be much bolder and more versatile than powdered blush. A little goes a really long way. I also use a small amount to darken my natural foundation if I need to during the summer.

I typically use a makeup brush to apply this foundation but you can also easily use your fingers. The basic ingredients are the same as the liquid foundation recipe and there are two options for this recipe: the simple way or the DIY way.

  1. For a simpler version, use a natural pre-made moisturizer for the base and add colors and pigments as needed.
  2. The DIY way takes a little more time and five ingredients but allows more customization since you’re making the base lotion yourself.

If you prefer the simple option, these two lotions are both are rated as safe by the Environmental Working Group and they make a great base:

For the DIY version, you’ll need these ingredients for the base:

And these ingredients to add to the base for color:

Creme Blush Ingredients

  • 1 teaspoon of shea butter
  • 1/2 tsp emulsifying wax
  • 1 tablespoon aloe gel
  • OR 1 tablespoon of natural pre-made lotion (in place of first 3 ingredients)
  • 1/2 – 1 teaspoon cocoa powder
  • 1/2 – 1 teaspoon mica powders of choice
  • OR 1-2 teaspoons of all-natural mineral powder in color of choice

Creme Blush Instructions

  1. If making the simple version… just mix the organic lotion and mineral powder (or mica powder and cocoa powder) to get the desired color and consistency.
  2. For the complete DIY:
  3. Melt the shea butter,and emulsifying wax in a double boiler until completely melted.
  4. Add the aloe and whisk until completely incorporated and smooth.
  5. Turn heat off.
  6. Slowly, start adding colors.
  7. Add mica powders and cocoa powder a tiny pinch at a time until desired color is reached.
  8. Dip the tip of a spoon into the mixture and let cool for a few seconds. Test the color and coverage on your cheek to make sure you’ve achieved the right tone for your skin.
  9. Spoon the mixture into the desired container and let cool.

Additional Tips

  • For a powdered version, check out this recipe and check out my other homemade makeup recipes here.
  • Adding colors (mica powders and cocoa powder) to a pre-made lotion will create a very smooth blush/bronzer. Experiment with the colors until you get the desired shade. It will look much darker while making it that it will on skin.
  • Making a homemade lotion as a base will give the most options for customizing but is also the most difficult. With the homemade one, adding more vegetable wax will make a thicker and longer lasting blush/bronzer while using more aloe will make a smoother and more subtle mix.
  • Adding more reddish mica powders will give a more rose/pink hue like a blush while more cocoa powder or bronze mica will create a bronzer or more tan mixture.

Ever made your own makeup?

Make your own natural creme blush or bronzer with this simple recipe using lotion made from shea butter and aloe plus minerals and natural colors.

You May Also Enjoy These Posts...

Reader Interactions

It Shouldn’t Be This Hard to Be Healthy…

Become a Wellness Mama VIP member for free and get access to my handbooks & quick start guides to help you detox your home, become a master of home remedies, make beauty products from scratch, and conquer mealtime madness!

Yes! Let me in!

Wellness Mama widget banner

Reader Comments

  1. I LOVE all of your posts! Thanks for all your hard work?? As for the DIY make-up. Mica is generally a no-no when making healthy safe skin products!! Would love to see recipes without it!

    • what do you mean it’s a no-no??

    • why is it a no-no?

      yes! i’d love to see recipes without it.


    • Agreed. Mica it’s not considered “natural” and I can’t use it in my soaping if it’s to be considered natural. Micas are lab-created colorants.

      • I use beets! Or beet root powder for both cheek and lip stains

      • Any thoughts on what to add to eye shadow for the same shimmer effect that mica has?

      • I am a geologist. Actually, mica is a natural mineral found all over the earth. It is shiny and platy. The two most common are called muscovite (usually translucent-ish) and biotite (usually has a black sheen). Therefore, it is 100% natural. However, I do not know anything about the safety of applying it to your face. Remember, not everything that is natural is always safe, either. Women used to use cinnabar as rogue but it contains mercury. So not safe, but natural.

        • Exactly…Mica is toxic and not to be inhaled or used on skin.

    • Mica is actually a natural mineral. It is powdered in a lab, but it is not lab created.

      • Not too sure about that go on line look it up mica known to cause cancer.

    • I make a brilliant red with diy hibiscus flower extract!

  2. Is this solid enough to put into a tube? Thank you for all the wonderful ideas and recipes by the way!

  3. Where do you get your various makeup brushes? Having trouble finding good ones..

    • woooooooooow!!!!!!!!!! 😀 thankzzz for all those great tips ^_^

    • Eco tools or real techniques! You can find them at Walmart. Eco tools is cruelty free and eco friendly. Both brands are very, very soft too.

  4. Can I substitute something for the aloe vera gel? I only have aloe vera juice.

  5. I have found a terrific way of making a very moisturizing BB cream. I used an old moisturizing jar and added about a teaspoon of moisturizer and added about a half teaspoon on mineral powder scrapings into the jar. Mixing them together with a tooth pick, I have found a very good product. It moisturizes, covers and blends just as well as a store bought BB cream. I didn’t think it would work, but I was pleasantly surprised. I also made a lip gloss from cocoa butter and a slice of a lipstick that was too dark. Mixing them together in a smaller container makes a great lip gloss.

  6. My daughter received a “play makeup kit” for Christmas one year, and its been sitting on a high shelf in my laundry room waiting for me to decide what to do about it. At first, I just thought she was too young do be putting on makeup, even “play makeup,” but now I don’t want to let her use it because God only knows what’s in it (there are no ingredients listed on the case).

    I was looking at some of your recipes, thinking I might be able to come up with some replacement options based off of them, but are there any natural ingredients that could give me some of the more vibrant colors typical to a child’s makeup kit (blues, purples, etc.)?

    And is there anything I could add to prevent spoilage? Im sure if I succeed in remaking this kit with natural options, its going to become the latest rage among my daughter and all her girl cousins, so there may end up being a lot of fingers touching these things. Will vitamin e oil, or maybe grapefruit seed extract help them not spoil?

    • I have food recipes from my Gramma that say to cook spinach in water and use the green water as food coloring. I’ve never done it yet. I suppose flower petals of whatever color you’d like could be dried and powderized in a blender or mortar and pestle. I think they would become perrishable again if made into a wet makeup. Maybe you could teach her how to carefully mix her own once you make the ingredients and mix bases, leaving final mixing for her to do as she uses.

  7. You could cook some beet root or red cabbage & use the coloring water.
    juice from a pomegranate or orange gives fab colors.
    Also purple head broccoli water.
    cook some blackberries then use the coloring water.
    Coffee or tea gives good color.
    Carrot juice might be another one.
    Then add some vitamin E as your preservative.

  8. Can you substitute bees wax for the emulsifying wax?

    • No, since the emulsifying wax is necessary to get the aloe and the shea butter to mix. Beeswax simply won’t do that.

  9. I like the ones that don’t use animal’s for testing. Some in stores are harsh on the skin.

  10. I use my everyday moisturizer with some cocoa powder. It works ok…wish i had the ingredients for the other options!!! ;p Also, anything for a DIY bronzer?

  11. Hey Mama!! I wanted to say Thank you for sharing all this healthy advice! I made my own blush with coconut oil, bees wax, cornstarch and beet powder. I remember seeing it on this site somewhere but I don’t remember where it is located. I found that it really gives my face a cute blushey glow. I had to use a blush brush to apply it, but it is great. I also use it for lipstick. Now I just need to learn to make mascara, eye shadow and shampoo and then I will be completely chemical free!!

  12. hi … I have some concern about this recipe … is mica safe to use ?? Can I use something different besides mica?

    • Mica is safe for the face. Inhaling it isn’t. Mica is used in all makeup as a light colorant with iron oxides (crushed rock) for color and sheen/sparkle. I make mineral makeup and only use certified safe micas and minerals. You can get mica from TKB trading. If you want to make this with color, you need to use either iron oxides or mica, beetroot and other herbs do not have opacity and will not put much color on your face. If you use a powder blush or lipstick to color it, you will be putting not only mica but other minerals on your face as well. I hope this helps.

      • Mica also has a natural sunscreen protection.

  13. Is there another option instead of Cocoa Powder? Chocolate triggers my migraines, so I’m afraid to try this. Thanks Wellness Mama!

    • Cinnamon perhaps? 🙂

  14. Another option other than Shea butter for those of us allergic to latex?

  15. Do you have a recipe for a primer? I would like to try making my own, but need some suggestions, as to the contents. Have not used one, but have seen videos of their use, and thought I would try it.

    Love all your recipes, making the beef broth as we speak.


  16. I recently made a few batches of this, substituting beetroot powder instead of mica powder. I was really happy with out it turned out until a few weeks later when the edges started to turn black and mold. I used the same metal jars that you have pictured on your blog. Have you had this issue at all? Could it be the beetroot powder?

    • I haven’t had that problem at all… perhaps that could be the problem? I don’t know if the beet root powder rehydrated and became able to mold.

  17. Hi there! Just wondering if this recipe could be used as a base for a cream eyeshadow as well?

  18. Could i use bees wax and just leave out the aloe?

    • It will create a thicker base, but it should work…

  19. Can I use your homemade natural lotion as a base?
    (olive oil, coconut oil, beeswax, shea butter, vitamin e)

    • Yes, it will just be rather oily, so it will be better if you have dry or combination skin…

  20. Do you have any photos where you’re wearing your homemade makeup? I’d love to see how the coverage is and how the mascara and blush look. Love your recipes and I can’t wait to try them! I already tried a few including a face scrub, toner and face moisturizer. Everything works wonderfully and I’m so glad to be using all natural/organic solutions. Thank you for sharing all this awesome information! 🙂

  21. Hi I try to use beet root powder to make cream blush but the powder just won’t dissolve in the oil, then what should I do?

    • Beet root or hibiscus powder is not oil soluble, It will be gritty anyway. You need to get either mica or red iron oxide! =)

  22. Why are all of the vital words missing when I look at your website? ( i.e. Ingredients for making things etc) I love everything you’re sharing. I just can’t make it because I can’t read all of it:(

    • I’m not sure what you’re referring to. None of the words are missing in the recipe. What type device and browser are you using to view the site?

  23. Have you ever tried Beautycounter products? What are your thoughts? I wanted to try a few products and they seem to be on the safer side.

  24. do i wait for it to cool off first or immediately add the powder right after i turn off the heat?

  25. My local zero waste store didn’t have red mica but it had a warm red iron oxide. I mixed that with a one-ingredient moisturizer (jojoba esters from Uncle Harry) and the result was CRAZY pigmented and long-lasting! Just 2 ingredients! Super impressed!