Is Yerba Mate Tea Better for You Than Coffee?

Is Yerba Mate Tea Better for You Than Coffee

Yerba mate tea boasts some surprising health benefits and may even replace your morning cup of Joe. Much like green tea, yerba mate tea is rich in polyphenols and antioxidants, and is quite tasty to boot.

Coffee Is King

Coffee is the undisputed king of all morning beverages. Readers ask my secret to getting things done and the answer involves at least 60% coffee!

Kidding aside, we all crave that delicious, robust flavor (which is why many people even get out of bed in the morning). And if you’re in a midday slump (or just tired from staying up all night with a fussy baby), an afternoon cup can often provide enough energy to help make it through the rest of the day without falling asleep. Oh yeah, and it even has some antioxidants that provide health benefits!

Then there’s the social aspect … sipping a latte with friends, or sharing a pot with coworkers.

But the competition steps up! Yerba mate has an impressive host of health benefits and can satisfy in much the same way that coffee does. It has a unique, rich flavor that’s similar to black or green tea. In South America, drinking yerba mate tea (often from gourds) is a common social pastime.

What’s in Yerba Mate?

Yerba mate tea is made from the leaves of the ilex paraguariensis plant. It’s been used for centuries in South America for medicinal purposes and as a social beverage.

Yerba mate does contain the stimulants caffeine and theobromine (also found in chocolate). Coffee contains about 85 milligrams of caffeine per 5 ounce cup, and yerba mate has slightly less at about 78 milligrams.

Yerba mate also contains anti-inflammatory saponins, chlorophyll, and potent antioxidants.

The Benefits of Yerba Mate

This tasty drink has some surprising health benefits!

Antioxidant Rich

Yerba mate protects DNA from free radical damage and has a high antioxidant capacity. It’s been shown to help protect against breast and colon cancers and has anti-tumor properties. One study found that those who consumed the most yerba mate tea, were least likely to have breast cancer, even when other factors like antioxidant consumption from other sources were accounted for.

Heart Healthy

Yerba mate not only protects against cellular damage but also protects the heart. This tea benefits the entire cardiovascular system. It works in part by dilating the blood vessels for better circulation.

Brain Boosting

Yerba mate stimulates the central nervous system to bring about both energy and focus. The tea protects the brain, improves memory, helps reduce depression, and can even help protect against Alzheimer’s disease. Yerba mate was even shown in one study to reduce the amount and length of epileptic seizures, while reducing oxidative damage in the brain.

Yerba mate drinkers can also improve hypothalamus function, a part of the brain that produces and regulates hormones in the body.

Anti-inflammatory

When sugar is consumed, a process called glycation happens. Glycation causes damage to the body’s proteins, which can result in inflammatory diseases like arthritis, fibromyalgia, and dementia.

Yerba mate tea has potent anti-glycation actions. One study found it prevented glycation formation by a whopping 83%. This isn’t a free license to eat a bunch of sugary treats, but yerba mate can help prevent damage from the fructose found in fruit and other sources.

Weight-Loss Friendly

Yerba mate has long been used for weight loss, and studies have shown it prevents body weight gain and reduces total body fat. It helps the body more efficiently burn fat and curbs the appetite for a feeling of satiety.

Even more impressive, yerba mate also inhibited visceral fat, the kind that collects along the waistline and abdominals. Visceral fat can surround vital organs like the liver and heart, and can contribute to heart disease, diabetes and other serious issues.

Protects Against Diabetes

Not only does yerba mate reduce potentially diabetes causing visceral fat, but it also improves insulin levels.

In one study diabetics and pre-diabetics drank yerba mate, and some of them made diet changes. Blood glucose levels improved across the board for all groups, but even more so for those who tried to eat healthier. The “healthy” diet they adopted followed food pyramid guidelines and was low in healthy saturated fats, so maybe if they ate a traditional foods diet they would have had even better results.

Liver Lovin’

Yerba mate works in much the same way to protect the liver. It helps to reduce oxidative damage to the liver’s cells. It also helps protect the liver against fatty liver disease and pancreatitis by balancing triglyceride levels.

The Darker Side of Yerba Mate

There are a few things to be aware of before switching ditching the coffee for a yerba mate, however.

Yerba mate contains something called polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. These hydrocarbons are the same cancer-causing compounds found in tobacco and charred foods.

Depending on growing conditions, yerba mate can also contain varying levels of heavy metals like aluminum and lead.

To put this in perspective though, the average lead concentration in yerba mate tea is less than half of what the EPA considers safe for drinking water. Green tea, coffee, and even fruits and vegetables also contain varying amounts of heavy metals in them, since it’s naturally abundant in soil.

And while yerba mate tea does contain low levels of certain carcinogens, it’s also very high in cancer-fighting antioxidants.

How to Prepare Yerba Mate Tea

Traditionally, yerba mate tea leaves are brewed in hollowed out gourds and sipped through bombillas, a metal straw with a strainer at the bottom. The gourd is passed around and the water refilled up to 20 times. The traditional recipe results in a very strong beverage, as the gourd is packed with leaves.

But never fear, gourds not required! You can make yerba mate at home in a French press, coffee pot, or with a simple household strainer.

Generally, for every 1 cup of water use a heaping 1 teaspoon of ground yerba mate.

  • To make yerba mate tea in a coffee pot, use 4 TBSP of the leaves for a 12-cup coffee pot and brew as usual.
  • If using a French press, add yerba mate tea to the press, then pour very hot but not boiling water over it. Let this steep for 3-8 minutes, depending on preference.
  • If using a strainer, add the yerba mate to a pot of very hot water, cover, and let steep for 3-8 minutes. Use a fine mesh strainer to filter out the leaves and pour into a cup.

Yerba mate tea can be enjoyed with a little raw cream or milk. It can also be sweetened with maple syrup, raw honey, or stevia if desired. You can even serve it cold, traditionally called tereré.

Are you a Yerba Mate tea drinker? Do you think you’ll start now after learning the benefits?

Sources:

Yerba Mate tea is an antioxidant rich tea with a host of benefits from liver supporting to weight loss friendly (but one major caution). Find out more...

You May Also Enjoy These Posts...

Reader Interactions

It Shouldn’t Be This Hard to Be Healthy…

Become a Wellness Mama VIP member for free and get access to my handbooks & quick start guides to help you detox your home, become a master of home remedies, make beauty products from scratch, and conquer mealtime madness!

Yes! Let me in!

Wellness Mama widget banner

Reader Comments

  1. Do you drink all these stimulants while nursing? I do occasionally but…am concerned about nursing moms on coffee or yerba or any stimulants. What do you really think about this?
    I myself am sipping Shatavari Tea.

    • Check with your Doctor or midwife if you’re concerned, but it’s never been an issue for me…

    • Hola Flora !
      I’m from Argentina, here is usual drink “mate cebado” (with straw) during nursing time.
      I did with my two babies and never had problem neither the boys, no sleeping problem
      i breastfeeding until 2 1/2 years old.

  2. Ok, this has convinced me to kick coffee for this ( for a little while). I have Hashimotos and with some stressful events recently, it has flared big time. Which I’ve responded to by drinking copious amounts of coffee )))-;;…bad girl, I know, but hey it had collagen and grass fed butter so not all bad ;-). But I’ve tried Yerba Mate before and loved it, so I will definitely be doing this!

  3. I have been drinking Yerba Mate for a few years now. Most mornings i have a large mug with two tea bags in it. Then I have my coffee with canned coconut milk and stevia. Coffee first upsets my stomach. And I love both of my morning drinks! Give it a try.

  4. You said, ” The “healthy” diet they adopted followed food pyramid guidelines and was low in healthy saturated fats, so maybe if they ate a traditional foods diet they would have had even better results.”

    Not everyone is suited to the diet that you follow and which many folks do indeed benefit from eating.

    Some people do well eating non-traditionally, which includes the avoidance or minimization of saturated fats. I agree with you that prediabetics are likely more suited to your kind of diet.

    Those people who do adopt the food pyramid guidelines and who may eventually, some time later, develop symptoms of ill health one way or another – it is always attributed to their diet. However, I have noticed that people who eat the low- or no-grain, healthy saturated fat, high-animal product, etc. type diet that you describe as “traditional” also eventually become ill one way or another – but they never blame their diet. It’s always “stress” or “heredity” or some drug they took long ago or this or that. Same with the high carb/adequate protein/low fat diet: nobody seems able to say, “Well, this was good for me for a period of time, but not for the rest of my life.”

    I consider the “traditional” diet to be suited to some people some of the time.
    I consider the more carb-centered (with adequate protein), low-fat diet to be suited to some people some of the time, too. When I use the word “suited”, I mean that previous symptoms of ill health go away or are greatly reduced.

    In any case, we all have to reassess our way of eating over the years and make any necessary changes. Nothing is right for a person forever. Most of us need some kind of medicine or supplementation irrespective of our basic diet.

    Thank you for considering my viewpoint.

    P.S. I cannot tolerate coffee. Yerba mate is somewhat more suitable for me.

  5. I’ve been drinking it for years. I like it strong with a little lemon in it. It makes me feel great in the morning. I was reluctant to give up coffee but I just feel so much better this way and I do not crash later!

  6. does it taste like coffee? or at least close? that is what I’m looking for.

    • I’ve not tried this, but Dandy Blend is sorta kinda similar to coffee and not bad.

    • Not at all. I love the taste of coffee but my body was so addicted to the caffeine causing migraines if I didn’t have my cofffee at the same time every morning. If I slept in one morning I woke up with a migraine and confined to bed the rest of the day. Not fun. I switched to Yerba about 5 years ago. Never had problems with migraines. I don’t need it every day, although I do love the flavor. Guayaki has great flavors available in cans, Enlighten Mint is my favorite. (I don’t get paid for endorsing them)
      Try it!

    • I love coffee too. I drink it purely for the flavor; the caffeine doesn’t do much for me.

      Yerba mate doesn’t taste like coffee, but it’s got its own unique roasty flavor, which I also find delicious. Republic of Tea makes a Yerba Mate Latte blend that’s out of this world. It is so good brewed extra strong with hot milk and honey added. What a treat!

      I also like Dandy Blend. It’s a powdered blend of roasted dandelion root, chicory, and other things. It reminds me a bit more of coffee than yerba mate, but doesn’t have the caffeine. I like to make a mocha with it by blending it with hot milk, raw cacao powder, and sweetener. It’s delightful.

  7. @sharon: it is closer to green tea with a full body flavor. If you are looking for a coffee substitute that tastes like coffee try teccino. It is a blend of herbs, They even carry flavored ones..

  8. I’m probably one of the few people on earth that don’t like coffee. I don’t like the taste and this is the reason I don’t like tiramisu. I’m the crazy one, yeah! I love green tea and black tea. I’ll try this tea and let you know what I think of it.

  9. Does it taste like green tea? I love coffee and black tea but not green tea. I’d have to really hunt it out, so if would be good to know ahead of time. Thanks.

    • It tastes more like black tea but slightly more earthy to me. Definitely a different flavor than green tea.

      • Thanks! Worth trying.

  10. “I welcome open discussion and disagreement in comments,”

    No, you don’t.

  11. I had never heard of Yerba before I went to Paraguay about 10 years ago. They have it all. the. time. It very deeply ingrained into their culture. It bridges the gap between social classes, ages, race, etc. Anyway, never having heard of it I didn’t realize it contained caffeine since they drank it at all hours of the day and night. One morning I didn’t have any and wound up with a splitting headache. That’s when they told me it had caffeine. It is a wonderful drink indeed. My favorite preparation was adding dried chamomile to the Yerba. It’s such a delicious combination!

  12. I’ve been drinking maté for years! I began to drink it for its anti inflammatory benefits after a surgery. It was an acquired taste and I used to drink it straight. One day my husband bought a roasted blend and I’ve been hooked on that ever since. I’m not and have never been a coffee drinker so I don’t know how the roasted maté compares, but it’s soooo yummy! I also add a heaping Tbs of Trader Joe’s coconut cream for the added MCT benefits. And now I’ve taken to blending 1:2 roasted maté to crío brü. I steep that and then add my coconut cream. Seriously, my favorite thing in the morning and I know I’m doing something good for my body! I’m 39 yrs old with 4 kids. It’s my main goal to have a healthy body and keep up with them! And this has helped me stay the course. 🙂

  13. Thank you for sharing your yerba mate story! I love it! it HAS to be organic to be truly a healthy source. The magic is done as you explain, from the antioxidant power of the polyphenols. I drink it with stevia, as I prefer it a little sweet…. the best one is Anna Park yerba mate, because it is a gourmet limited production, and it’s flavor lasts much longer. Thank you for sharing the love for this healthy habit! Cheers!

  14. I would be dubious of anything with purported carcinogens in it. But that’s just me. At least coffee does not have known carcinogens in it. & I do not believe the presence of antioxidants somehow cancels out other carcinogenic properties from the same material.

  15. As an Uruguayan, I am delighted to see an article about Yerba Mate on your blog! I had no idea of all of its properties.
    For the Uruguayan, the “Mate” has a deeply cultural meaning, much more than the health benefits importance.
    I must confess though, I don’t think I would be interested in trying Mate in the form of tea because it would lose all of its meaning to me. The gourd+bombilla ritual has an enormous importance for Uruguayan/Argentinian people. Either we drink it by ourselves while studying alone or sharing the gourd with a happy group of friends in a circle, the Mate is much more about feeling accompanied that feeling nourished.
    (Of course it doesn’t mean you can’t have it in the form of tea! Just wanted to share my view).
    By the way: the gourd can be easily switched for a small mug or cup. In fact, industry has made available “mates” made out of ceramic, glass and even silicone. There is a mate for each and everyone! So if you ever feel interested in trying uruguayan/argentinian mate, the only different thing you will need is the bombilla. 🙂

  16. I have to say that Yerba Mate does not taste like coffee, the closer tea that does is Pu erh tea in cake form: https://www.amazon.com/Yunnan-Pu-erh-Tea-12-Oz-340/dp/B002IY2VL2/ref=as_li_ss_tl?ie=UTF8&linkCode=ll1&tag=wellnessmama-20&linkId=02a0790b7d6b3190f3caeca1bc354fd6. The thing with Yerba Mate, is truly make sure you don’t have a serotonin sensitivity before drinking, because it does contain MAOI. If you are sensitive it can not make you relax and be alert, but truly grumpy.

  17. I’m new here and I’m glad i got to know about this site. I’m in Nigeria.
    Pls my case is on fertility, how to build ovulation. I met a gynecologist, who said my problem is just that i dnt ovulate. After taking clomid, i stil didn’t see any result
    Pls do you have any post on natural way i can be helped.

Join the Conversation...

Please read the comment policy before replying to this post.